like they keep mentioning! with the whitelighter and having a half whitelighter baby!

but shes like grams too!

I chose Patty. Piper was very much like her early on, but I could see how she could take after Grams later on when she became head witch. Patty won because of the whitelighter similarity.

Hmmm... grams was also less successful with the men!

I just think they act a lot alike. But it's true that history is kind of repeating itself from Patty to Piper.

Patty,because they're nice and lovely

i think....