There's a theory floating around that Claire is already dead, she died when her house was rocketed. As of now, she is a ghost of apparition, similar to Christian Shepard of Charlie.
For the theory
- Claire wasn't hurt, even though the entire house was destroyed.
- Claire thought Sawyer was Charlie when he first found her. It is possible that she actually was talking to Charlie, before she came to.
- This is why she leaves with Christain, another apparition, and leaves Aaron.
- After Sawyer rescues Claire, he asks if she is all right. She antwoorden with somethign along the lines of "at least I'm not seeing things anymore". Perhaps this is because had 'crossed over'.
- Most of Claire's storyline seems to have been explained. The writers may have decided to kill her off.
- This theory could also explain why Miles has taken a sudden interest in Claire.
Aginst the theory
- Claire wouldn't be able to interact with the Losties the way she does. (Though, as seen many times in Lost, the living interact with the dead many times.)
- Claire does not seem to know she's dead, of seem troubled door it.
- She can hold Aaron. (However, we also see Chrstian holding Aaron, though it could be that he is actually alive.)
- Claire seems drugged in Jacob's cabin, as if that was how Christian got her there, not because they were both "ghosts".
- In "Something Nice Back Home", Charlie's message to Jack is that he isn't supposed to raise Aaron. This could mean Claire is still alive and she is the one who Aaron is supposed to be with.
For the theory
- Claire wasn't hurt, even though the entire house was destroyed.
- Claire thought Sawyer was Charlie when he first found her. It is possible that she actually was talking to Charlie, before she came to.
- This is why she leaves with Christain, another apparition, and leaves Aaron.
- After Sawyer rescues Claire, he asks if she is all right. She antwoorden with somethign along the lines of "at least I'm not seeing things anymore". Perhaps this is because had 'crossed over'.
- Most of Claire's storyline seems to have been explained. The writers may have decided to kill her off.
- This theory could also explain why Miles has taken a sudden interest in Claire.
Aginst the theory
- Claire wouldn't be able to interact with the Losties the way she does. (Though, as seen many times in Lost, the living interact with the dead many times.)
- Claire does not seem to know she's dead, of seem troubled door it.
- She can hold Aaron. (However, we also see Chrstian holding Aaron, though it could be that he is actually alive.)
- Claire seems drugged in Jacob's cabin, as if that was how Christian got her there, not because they were both "ghosts".
- In "Something Nice Back Home", Charlie's message to Jack is that he isn't supposed to raise Aaron. This could mean Claire is still alive and she is the one who Aaron is supposed to be with.