5. Ariel and Eric - tour of kingdom and boat ride
6. Aurora and Philip - dance in the forest
7. Tiana and Naveen - the dance in the bayou
8. Pocahontas and John - nature walk
9. Mulan and Shang - the dinner proposal
10. Snow and Florian - singing at the balcony

Please note that the ideal criteria for choosing an option for elimination should be basis the scenes in the film. What was included in the date - dinner/walk/ride/town tour etc, the setting of the scene (forest/ballroom/garden/lake and how exotic/beautiful it is, the romantic emotions between the couple (not from entire movie but in the scene itself).
Also, please consider the entire situation. For ex: Philip flirting with Aurora before dancing will be part of the date.

Aw, so sad Ariel and Eric left. :( Their date is both fun and romantic imo. This date is very magical, but I would feel uncomfortable with all of the people watching me dance with a guy I barely knew.

the walk in the private gardens is just gorgeous with fountains and moon shining on the river...but yes, i agree to maidoforleans, so many people watching me dance would make it awkward, esp the King himself.

Very similar to Ariel's Tour of the Kingdom, this was a nice date with romantic events such as touring the town and going for a boat ride. (I think the events of the other dates are equally or more romantic though.) The lantern setting is nice with the lanterns but not really my taste. (I prefer the stars to lanterns and grass or courtyards to little boats on the water.) It was sweet that they were starting to fall in love but the fact that he was hiding his identity from her as a thief on the loose and she was anxious about what her mother had just told her about him not loving her, made it awkward for them and they seemed unable to voice their feelings at first, since this technically wasn't a date in that it wasn't planned that way. (Whereas the other dates on this were more openly romantic.) As soon as they were about to kiss and show their feelings, they were interrupted by the Stabbington(?) Twins and Mother Gothel takes away from the romance of it to me. (Though the other dates had their interruptions too.)

While this was a great scene, I consider the other dates to be more romantic. It was pretty short too.

Aww, Eric&Ariel's town date was so lovely :(
However as I said before, I was struggling between this and Cindy's 1st date, but Cindy really enjoyed her time with the Prince. And I think a dance in a crowded ballroom isn't that bad, especially if you're dancing with the crown Prince and you are wearing a stunning ballgown. Yeah, I'd enjoy that <3
Belle kinda looks like to me that she hasn't got better thing to do, so "okay, let's have dinner and dance".

Same as before.

I like Mrs. Potts singing for Belle and the Beast. But when it comes down to it...I don't feel the romance really happening between Belle and Adam during the ballroom scene. Sure, Belle leans on his chest, and Cogsworth and Lumiere cheer, but I don't really feel that it is romantic. It is more of a friendship being honored.

Also, just sharing a meal, doing a little dancing, and sitting on a balcony isn't all that exciting to me. The minute Beast asks Belle if she is happy, Belle emits this heavy sigh which kills the mood for me. No, Belle isn't happy. Belle is still thinking about her dad. Belle isn't romantically involved in this as much as Beast is. When the beast takes Belle to the West Wing and gives her the mirror, I feel sorry for beast, not for Belle. Belle is again preoccupied with her own interest in her dad. It's as if this whole evening the beast planned, where the beast is trying to get Belle romantically interested in him, was a rushed endeavor and no longer counts.

This is the least romantic one for me of the ones left. Basically, Belle just ruins the moment in the end.

Tough choices, all of them are romantic. I pick this more because the duration of this scene is shorter than the others.

Shorter scene and I don't really see much romance going on for me.