Cinderella's tiara does look a bit like one you would get for a 6 year old to wear for her birthday. Like you could buy Cindy's tiara at Claires. Still, it has a better shape then Tiana's tiara.

I agree with SarahCorine's statement that it looks like a cheap plastic tiara made for a toddler, so it definitely gets my vote. I don't mind the shape of Tiana's tiara, in fact I really like how simple it is. I also love the combo of peridot and gold. So beautiful!

I like that it's simple and not overdone but I think the other is prettier and fits the princess better.

I love the jewels in Cinderella's tiara - blue sapphire and diamonds but i like the simple elegance of Tiana's tiara. also love the unique Peridot jewel used in this. I love the shape of it, far much better.

Such an ugly, plastic looking toy tiara. I don't like it.
Tia's tiny tiara is very delicate and elegant, fits for her perfectly.

This tiara is too small and have weird shape. Cinderella's tiara has better colors and shape rather than this tiara.

The shape is really weird.

I'm not fond of oblong jewels in tiaras. Also, this tiara is not as nicely shaped as the others, including Cindy's.

Not a great tiara shape.

Cinderella's looks pretty childish.

Looks like Sonoko Suzuki of Detective Conan

I'm not a big fan of either but I slightly prefer Cindy's.

It's quite small and the design isn't great.