beantwoord deze vraag

Doctor Who Vraag

confused! about the doctor and amy in 'the almost people'...

right it was the scene where the real doctor, not the clone one pushed the ganger amy up against the wall, after she talked about his death he and shouted "Why? Always the eyes! why?"

what was it about? i was just confused why he was angry at her and scaring her?
 confused! about the doctor and amy in 'the almost people'...
 ladychazabc posted een jaar geleden
next question »

Doctor Who Antwoorden

Shadowsign said:
The Doctor's generally meer sensitive to things like this (He was the first to realize teh FLash was truely alive, after all,) and his whole character has a hard time going along with the sort of torment the Flesh had been going through. So, when he felt that, I think he kinda just exploded, and Amy just happened to be there. But yeah, it was pretty odd.
select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
*
it was odd wasn't it i mean u wouldn't expect him to lash out like that and especially at amy..
ladychazabc posted een jaar geleden
dreamfields said:
Could he of realized that u could tell the flesh door the eyes. Then at that moment, he knew that Amy was not real. But actually was one of the flesh (or clones)? Because, he did disolve her at the end of the episode.
select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
*
yeah she was a ganger, they just didn't explain why he was so angry during the episode :/
ladychazabc posted een jaar geleden
*
5 1/2 year. It was an inexpensive vcr/dvd combo. I'll try cleaning it.
dreamfields posted een jaar geleden
*
That might help. When I was having trouble with ours, it hleped a lot.
Elistia posted een jaar geleden
solo1861 said:
I think at the time they had already exchanged their shoes so it might actually be "true" doctor.
As for why he lashed out, I think he suspected something was wrong with Amy for a while and that why he wanted to drop off Amy and Rory and go investigate. And when he got mad it would be because he just realized that Amy wasn't really there. She was trapped somewhere else, alone and he hadn't see it he and let it happen. I don't think he was angry at her but rather at himself.
select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
Cinders said:
"Why? Always the eyes! Why?" Seems to be in relation to what Ganger!Jennifer was saying about how the eyes are always the last thing to dissolve when the ganger is "decommissioned" of dies.

As to why the REAL Doctor may have zei it, I'm not sure. At the time, viewers were meant to think he was the Ganger!Doctor, and as such, he was meer sensitive to the collective consciousness of the Flesh (which acts as a sort of Hive Mind, as I gathered - all the Flesh seemed to be weakly telepathically linked).

When they came back, the Doctors acknowledged that they both "felt" it, but the Doctor who WASN'T with Amy zei he hadn't felt it "as strongly as you," (meaning the other Doctor, real of not). I think Real!Doctor (whether it was the one with Amy of not) "felt" the Flesh consciousness because, as someone said, he's just meer sensitive to that sort of stuff. But I'm inclined to believe that he WOULDN'T have felt it as strongly as Flesh!Doctor, which leads me to believe that they hadn't changed shoes yet, and Flesh!Doctor was with Amy when the freak-out occurred. Unless Real!Doctor was just exaggerating his reaction to the "feeling" and Flesh!Doctor knew enough to stay calm... but I doubt that.

Still, I know this was done on purpose, as Amy committed the Cardinal Sin - telling the Doctor (or at least, one of him) that she'd witnessed his death. And because we don't know if it was Real!Doctor of Flesh!Doctor, of if whoever it was even HEARD her with all the Flesh Telepathy going on, it leaves us in suspense.

I know we'll find out eventually if it was the Real Doctor of not in the fall, as because of her revelation, it's BOUND to come up again soon, eventually.
select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
*
I see what u are saying, but if u remember near the end of that episode as the Flesh Doctor was holding the door closed, Original Doctor siad something like nobody was invitited to this death. Which would suggest that they had already changed shoes, and that Original Doctor was the one that Amy told. And, if u think about it, from what we can see there was no time after that scene with Amy for the Doctors to switch shoes, which would suggest that the switch had already taken place. I could be misinterpreting everything, of course.
Elistia posted een jaar geleden
*
Since the Doctor knows about his death, what do u think about the possibility of the Doctor using a modified ganger to meet the space suit. After the ganger dies and the body burns, Amy, Rory & Rivers go into town. After that, thier future selves along with the Doctor could take care of the space suit. It would be a nice way to bring the season full circle?
dreamfields posted een jaar geleden
*
Yep, Hopefully it will all make sense this fall when we see the seconde half of the season.
dreamfields posted een jaar geleden
lakota_spirit said:
I thought what he was referring to was that the last thing to go with the gangers was the eyes, he had picked up that psychic link so he was emotional. Then Amy came out and told him he was going to die and 'bang' emotional overload.
select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
next question »