Hiccup is ugly while Jack Frost is quite good-looking. Jack Frost looks like an anime character.

Hiccup is not super handsome, in fact his appearance is rather dorky, but that is one of the reasons I love him as a character. He breaks the mold and is adorable doing it.

I don't know his age so I don't want to perve on him too much! lol

Jack has been 18 for 300 years, so I don't think you have to worry about being a perv, lol. ;)

Both are great

@missamitza: haha thank you! i figured he was 15-18 (haven't seen the movie yet)

Jack is more handsome... but Hiccup has this cute factor I love in males, so I'll just pick the cutest instead of the coolest.

to the people/person who said that hiccup is ugly/dorky looking LOOK UP HTTYD2 and i noticed that the creator of this poll is very biased because she was the one who made this i bet just to look for an argument yes jack is rather atrractive but he is nothing like an anime charater i should know......hiccup is just so sweet and cutely roundfaced and just to little is adorable he's a hiccup :)

Jack is so cute!

awwh that's rude about hiccup hiccup is adorable yeah his eyes do look weird but jack frost looks awesome ill make him to make a ladder so I can go up to heaven and bring grama back to the world what ya say!!!!!!!!!! wrong answer

He is sooo cute in the 2nd movie!! <3

Hiccup is even cuter in the first movie

Honestly, idk which one is better. Well, I think Jack Frost looks better than 15-year-old Hiccup but I think Hiccup in the 2nd and 3rd movie looks better than Jack Frost xD