i don't think they would even if they should . But i suppose he was sent to Southern Isles to his twelve brothers. They would give him his punishment, i mean twelve brothers! I kinda pity him. As for me, i would only imprison him, bescuz his crime wasn't that great(to me) and i understand why he did what he did.
I know this is answer is going to make me very unpopular, but the vraag what I think Hans's punishment SHOULD be, not what I think it was, and not what I think the other Frozen fans would want it to be, and the truth is I don't think there should be a punishment.
Before anybody jumps to the wrong conclusion, this DOES NOT mean I advocate his actions because I don't... at all. But I do know what it's like to be ignored, and I understand that sometimes when u vie for someone's approval for as long as Hans did, it's easy to lose sight of right and wrong. And I know how it feels to make a mistake and be denied a seconde chance, so I'm not about to point fingers and condemn Hans for his.
I prefer forgiveness over retribution, and I don't think there's such a thing as a person who is beyond redemption. As far as I'm concerned, there's only one true brand of justice in the world, and that happens when someone atones for their actions of their own accord, not just because society demands it. So I would hope that Hans would realize the error of his ways and try to make it right on his own, but I can't in good conscience take it upon myself to decide what he deserves.
I think, Elsa should freeze the portion where Hans fell due to Anna's punch. Then he should be kept in the prison and later sent back to The Southern Isles with a letter saying 'Please take care of your brother because he has done so many things at Arendelle' and then his brothers will take care of him
I don't think Hans felt guilty for what he did. As far as i remember, there's no sign of him feeling guilty during the whole movie. So he obviously deserves some punishment. Maybe something harsh, coz what he did was harsh too. Trying to kill someone is no joke. so maybe he should be punished in a way that can make him realize his mistakes and be a better person.
He should be locked out in a dark place and nobody should be able to talk with him. Not even the people who works in the prision. So the real punishment should be absolute silence being invisible for the rest of his life.