One of my favorites ever!!!

I didn't like Big Brother for many reasons for one the episode after OMW should have been about Quinn. I think Blaine deseves a storyline but the episode shouldn't have come after the hiatus.Now if I were just comparing the episodes I think I would still chose Theatricality I liked Rachels story line the numbers and Quinn/Puck subplot better. I honestly couldn't buy that ND was eating up Cooper's BS.

I agree with Piperlovegood, I liked Theatricality better. I liked everything in the episode. A plus point was Idina Menzel...

I'm still mad about Big Brother because I'm bitter over the whole way they carried on Quinn's storyline- barely at all; replacing it with BLANGST. What was shown of Quinn's feelings left much to be desired. They made her so comfortable and happy that it seemed they were going the route of her being internally angry and upset, but they didn't really touch on that. But beside the biterness and poor timing, I did not like the episode because I felt that Blaine's storyline was short and simple, that he overreacted and that the whole dilemma could've been solved without spending an episode on it. Also the seniors/juniors spending skip day at the amusement park was insensitive.

I also loved Theatricality for the costumes, simple, clean storytelling, Rachel finding out about Shelby being her mother, and Puck singing Beth.

I loved Big Brother because Cooper is oblivious but in the end he show that he loves her brother, and it's a episode of Blaine one point more, I agreed must have been more of Quinn but the episode was amazing!

I didn't like Theatrecality, I loved the costumes but the plot about Rachel and Shelby boring me... sorry, my opinion :)

Big Brother is one of my favorite episodes <3

Love both, but this episode was just EPIC!

This has always been one of my favourites, but also for the reasons that @piperlovegood and @Crime-Drama-Bee already said.

Theatricality is probably my favourite episode.