What do you think? Place your vote!
(Placed your vote already? Remember to login!)

Harry Potter Vs. Twilight Who do u feel worse for?

77 fans picked:
Moaning Myrtle- Made fun of her whole life then killed.
   69%
Rosalie Hale- Almost beaten to death door her husband, then turned into a vampire.
   31%
 MarlenaLovett posted een jaar geleden
Make your pick! | next poll >>
save

24 comments

user photo
TrueTwi_hard picked Moaning Myrtle- Made fun of her whole life then killed.:
I am totally pro-twilight, but still...
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
HecateA picked Rosalie Hale- Almost beaten to death door her husband, then turned into a vampire.:
I don't know... Myrtle could have stood up for herself I think. Rosalie was just... I don't know, abuse is just one of the worst things to go through in my mind, but she turned into a vampire which is better then ghost... Both are misunderstood and... I don't know.

I'll side with Twilight because I never do, so...
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
ArcticWolf picked Moaning Myrtle- Made fun of her whole life then killed.:
This was actually very close. Both went through traumatic events. But now Rosalie, upset as she was, at least had a family and at the end she was happy. Moaning Myrtle was and always will be miserable. She was picked on in her life and now everyone picks on her in her death - she's pretty much facing eternity in misery. I really don't blame her for whining and crying all the time, because if I were stuck in the same situation I would probably react the same way.
posted een jaar geleden.
last edited een jaar geleden
 
user photo
zanhar1 picked Moaning Myrtle- Made fun of her whole life then killed.:
^ Exsactly myrtle's pain doesnt end. Both are horrible though.
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
Drisina picked Moaning Myrtle- Made fun of her whole life then killed.:
Both i even remember when i was little and HP 2 came out in theaters ..when i was like 7 or 8 i was so terrified when she was showed , especially cause it was dark(duh)in the cinema lol.
You know what i picked Rosalie's at first but ArcticWolf's comment made me change my mind.
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
Ms_Mea picked Moaning Myrtle- Made fun of her whole life then killed.:
That's a scary pic of Rosalie *shivers*
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
jodarchy picked Moaning Myrtle- Made fun of her whole life then killed.:
there should be a both option lol, i think myrtle has it worse though she is doomed to spend an eternity being bullied, imagine dying and having to spend your afterlife in a place where you got bullied everyday, although rosalie had it tough as well
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
cassie-1-2-3 picked Moaning Myrtle- Made fun of her whole life then killed.:
Myrtle was just a kid.
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
LoopyLuna96 picked Rosalie Hale- Almost beaten to death door her husband, then turned into a vampire.:
I feel sorry for both euqally, really. But being beaten to death and being turned into a Meyerpire is a bit worse.
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
bri-marie picked Moaning Myrtle- Made fun of her whole life then killed.:
Rosalie got a happy ending out of the deal - she got Emmett and the rest of the Cullens. Myrtle was banished to a bathroom >.>
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
FredWRules picked Moaning Myrtle- Made fun of her whole life then killed.:
and don't forget, people kinda used her while she was a ghost, then left her alone.
like, Harry did.
and then he left her.
bastard :D
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
KateKicksAss picked Rosalie Hale- Almost beaten to death door her husband, then turned into a vampire.:
Rosalie got turned into a MeyerPire! What could be worse than THAT?

Sure Moaning Myrtle was made fun of, but at least she didn't end up as a sparkly fairy MeyerPire.
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
boolander25 picked Rosalie Hale- Almost beaten to death door her husband, then turned into a vampire.:
It's kinda close for me though. They both kind of got their revenge, but Rosalie's was pretty awful.
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
Darkshine picked Moaning Myrtle- Made fun of her whole life then killed.:
I feel sorry for both.
Myrtle was a CHILD,she was also completely misunderstood her whole life,got killed my a basilisk,then became the freak of the school for eternity. She lives in a BATHROOM!
Bur Rosalie,though got beaten up and became a Meyerpire.
Myrtle's death wasn't painful and she's a ghost. She's transprent.
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
Mongoose09 picked Rosalie Hale- Almost beaten to death door her husband, then turned into a vampire.:
I agree with KateKicksAss.
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
mina_sit picked Moaning Myrtle- Made fun of her whole life then killed.:
it's almost a tie but at least rosalie finds in emmet her peace...
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
ecpjll picked Rosalie Hale- Almost beaten to death door her husband, then turned into a vampire.:
i dont know who this is but being beaten almost to death by your husband would really suck.
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
SuperSnuffles13 picked Moaning Myrtle- Made fun of her whole life then killed.:
I feel badly for Rosalie, but she got a happy ending at least. Myrtle lives in a toilet.
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
zanhar1 picked Moaning Myrtle- Made fun of her whole life then killed.:
^ I know Harry even declined her offer to share it with him, how rude is that?!
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
xDark_Angelx picked Moaning Myrtle- Made fun of her whole life then killed.:
Myrtle has been made fun of and still is. Remember in the "Chamber of Secrets" when people were throwing stuff at her to see it go through. Myrtle will never get a happy ending; she'll spend her ghostly life in the toilet; she can't go anywhere! Myrtle never got love, either. Sure, she was young, but...you know, everyone thought she was crazy, both before and after her death.

Rosalie, though, does have somewhat of a good life. Sure, being a Meypire would be awful for us, even for her, since she can't have kids, but it provides a happy, never-ending life for her. She has Emmett and a good family who she loves. She' rich now and pretty much gets everything she wants.
posted een jaar geleden.
last edited een jaar geleden
 
user photo
RealSunshine picked Rosalie Hale- Almost beaten to death door her husband, then turned into a vampire.:
This is really sad :(
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
nickjonasfan001 picked Moaning Myrtle- Made fun of her whole life then killed.:
i feel more sorry for myrtle because she was getting bullied which we all experiance once in a whilexx
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
i-am-mariella picked Moaning Myrtle- Made fun of her whole life then killed.:
This was so tough. I felt awful for Rosalie - because she was raped and abused and all she wanted was a happy life, and although I don't like Twilight (understatement much?), I can't help but feel sorry for her and quite some parts of like her character.

But I had to go for Myrtle; because she was only a child, she had an atrocious life and then died young, and she was still getting bullied after she died, whereas Rosalie's afterlife was quite pleasant - she was beautiful and unbelievably rich (Myrtle lived in the girls' bathrooms), and she had a boyfriend and a family (Myrtle had no-one, except maybe Draco as her "friend").
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
BabyOwlLover4 picked Moaning Myrtle- Made fun of her whole life then killed.:
^Exactly. Before Rosalie was beaten and turned into a sparklepire, she had a great life. And after, She also had a great life. She killed her abuser and found her soul mate and a perfect family.

Myrtle had a terrible life, she was teased and tormented and she cried in the bathroom. She was only 12 or so when she died. Now she is stuck in between as a ghost and she is still teased.
posted een jaar geleden.