Harry Potter Article: Theory about RAB

30

posted by snoznoodle

I had a thought...

I'm sure I'm not the only one who is wondering how on earth Harry, Ron and Hermione could destroy all those horcruxes when Dumbledore, one of the greatest wizards ever almost died trying to destroy two of them.

And since Dumbledore and Harry really aren't the only ones who know about Voldemort's horcruxes, its possible that RAB has actually done the work for them without Voldemort realising it. Its possible that he actually destroyed all the horcruxes besides Nagini but somehow didn't live to tell anyone.

So the only horcrux that they would have to destroy would be the snake. Remember Voldemort only made Nagini a horcrux in Goblet of Fire. So she is at least one horcrux left that we know still exists.

I can't see Harry, Ron and Hermione managing to destroy 4 horcruxes without one of them dying of getting seriously injured. That could happen too however...

CAN'T WAIT TILL IT COMES OUT! 5 DAYS TO GO!

jaimiejo128, bdavis98 and 28 others like this

tinydancer I'm not sure about the idea that RAB has destroyed all the Horcruxes, but it's a good theory! I do totally agree about how the hell Harry, Ron and Hermione are gonna destroy all of them though, if even Dumbledore couldn't manage it! Guess we'll just have to wait and see, not long now!! I'm excited and also sad that it's almost over! :(

tubby2002 I think that even if RAB did destroy some or all of the other horcruxes it will still be very difficult for the trio becuase the one that really did Dumbledore in was the locket and it wasnt even a really Horcrux, but the one that was found by RAB. The trio will still have to look and find them and if they have already been destroyed then the search will be that much harder because they will have to find these things that dont even exsist anymore. But, yea, I have no clue how they are going to do this, when Dumbledore had so much trouble.

mattgrimes9 well ur theory was wrong and they do destroy all of the horcruxes with the help of neville who chops up nagini with godric gryfindor's sword

snoznoodle Yeah oh well. I liked it while it lasted.

phee34 well your right i seriously doubt they would have been able to on there on but what i think u don't realize is that yes dumbledore only managed to destroy 2 horcruxs phyiscally but he layed the plan and made it possible for harry, ron and hermoine to destroy the others..if he hadn't done all that for harry in his sixth year i think i could safely assume they'd would have maybe destroyed a couple before not knowing wat to do

snoznoodle I don't think I realised how layered the whole story is. How everything was set up to come into use at some point. I underestimated Joe's imagination, that's for sure.

Irina92 Well, check this out... They finally made it (for those who doubted it!) Of course they would. And as we see in the last book, Dumbledore had its drawbacks too... Besides, Dumbledores plans (almost) never fail! So don't ever underestimate someone!!

happyallie ok listin *SPOILER ALERT* RAB is Sirius Black's brother that they talk about in the beginning of the movie when Horace Slughorh is showing Harry pictures. also they do have to find a bunch of horcruxes, and, as you can guess, Harry almost dies in almost all of them. HERE'S A SUPER SPOILER!! Harry is a horcrux so he has to die too (watch the begin of the preview and that shows how it happens :))