What can I answer to that ?

Hi!!
Well, I have a little problem with one of my vrienden she zei that gay people are wrong because it's not natural and against the Bible and also that if every one was gay the human race would disappear. It's completly stupid right? Well Is there something I can tell her to change her mind?? (I really like her but it's difficult for me now to stay with her)
 Beckett-13 posted een jaar geleden
next question »

LGBT Antwoorden

Cinders said:
Homosexuality and the Bible

The passages that condemn homosexuality in the Bible (Leviticus 18:22, Romans 1:26) could be interpreted as condemning homosexual lust, in the same way that it condemns heterosexual lust, as it's discussing having gay sex out of wedlock, and having any sex out of wedlock is wrong.

On the other hand, the story of link shows that the Bible highly approves of strong male/male love and bonding. And while several homosexuality critics claim that their relationship was homosocial (strong bonds between men exceeding romantic love), however if this were true, I doubt that Saul would have been so upset with the relationship as it was.

Ergo, I'd like to think that the Bible promotes love of all kinds - including love between people of the same sex.

And even if u want to interpret the text as condemning homosexuality in all instances - love included - one has to remember that the Bible condemns several things, many of which are legal (gambling, drinking, adultery...), and many of which are downright ridiculous in this dag and age (wearing clothes made of different threads, touching the skin of a dead pig, eating shellfish, wearing gold...). The Bible also condones things that are illegal, including slavery and misogyny.

Reliability of this response: All of these arguments come straight out of the mouth of a lapsed Christian with deep respect for Christ and his religion. I've read meer of the Bible than some Christians I know who go to church every Sunday.

Homosexuality as Unnatural

As the graphic included in this answer attests, there are literally hundreds of animal species that engage in homosexual behavior, including our closest extant relatives, the chimpanzees and bonobos. Animals that form homosexual pair bonds (monogamous mates for life) include penguins, gibbons and swans.

In short, there is nothing unnatural about homosexuality. However, even if u want to ignore the evidence and claim that it is unnatural, human beings do not reject a concept of philosophy simply because it's unnatural. Synthetic fabrics, any tool of technology we use, even medical care and life-saving techniques are "unnatural" and yet we embrace all of those things. What makes homosexuality the odd eend out?

Reliability of Source: My information comes to me from two courses in biological anthropology and human sexuality at the universiteit level.

Homosexuality and Population

It's admittedly true that if the world were entirely 100% gay, then there would be no way for us to reproduce without technology like invitro fertilization. However, contrary to populair belief, gays are not trying to take over the world. Conversely, those against homosexuality are trying to purge it from the world. [More in comments]
select as best answer
 <u>Homosexuality and the Bible</u> The passages that condemn homosexuality in the Bible (Leviticus 18:22, Romans 1:26) could be interpreted as condemning homosexual <i>lust</i>, in the same way that it condemns heterosexual lust, as it's discussing having gay sex out of wedlock, and having any sex out of wedlock is wrong. On the other hand, the story of <a href="http://www.wouldjesusdiscriminate.org/biblical_evidence/david_jonathan.html">David and Jonathan</a> shows that the Bible highly approves of strong male/male love and bonding. And while several homosexuality critics claim that their relationship was homosocial (strong bonds between men exceeding romantic love), however if this were true, I doubt that Saul would have been so upset with the relationship as it was. Ergo, I'd like to think that the Bible promotes love of all kinds - including love between people of the same sex. And <i>even</i> if u want to interpret the text as condemning homosexuality in all instances - love included - one has to remember that the Bible condemns several things, many of which are legal (gambling, drinking, adultery...), and many of which are downright ridiculous in this dag and age (wearing clothes made of different threads, touching the skin of a dead pig, eating shellfish, wearing gold...). The Bible also <i>condones</i> things that are illegal, including slavery and misogyny. <b>Reliability of this response</b>: All of these arguments come straight out of the mouth of a lapsed Christian with deep respect for Christ and his religion. I've read meer of the Bible than some Christians I know who go to church every Sunday. <u>Homosexuality as Unnatural</u> As the graphic included in this answer attests, there are literally hundreds of animal species that engage in homosexual behavior, including our closest extant relatives, the chimpanzees and bonobos. Animals that form homosexual pair bonds (monogamous mates for life) include penguins, gibbons and swans. In short, there is nothing unnatural about homosexuality. However, even if u want to ignore the evidence and claim that it is unnatural, human beings do not reject a concept of philosophy simply because it's unnatural. Synthetic fabrics, any tool of technology we use, even medical care and life-saving techniques are "unnatural" and yet we embrace all of those things. What makes homosexuality the odd eend out? <b>Reliability of Source</b>: My information comes to me from two courses in biological anthropology and human sexuality at the universiteit level. <u>Homosexuality and Population</U> It's admittedly true that if the world were entirely 100% gay, then there would be no way for us to reproduce without technology like invitro fertilization. However, contrary to populair belief, gays are not <i>trying</i> to take over the world. Conversely, those against homosexuality are trying to <i>purge</i> it from the world. [More in comments]
posted een jaar geleden 
*
So let's assume this is that perfect world where there are no gays of gay couples. Currently, scientists estimate that one in ten people on the planet are gay. That's 10% of the population that's not breeding. However, in a "perfect world" that 10% is now suddenly "cured" of their homosexuality. Now, they want to get married to someone of the opposite sex and have a family, which is a perfectly reasonable want. Our population booms at a 10% faster rate, and we reach critical mass (the point where our resources cannot renew fast enough to support us) 10% sooner than usual. Now, that doesn't sound like a lot, but exponentially, a 10% difference can mean overpopulation and overcrowding could become a species-threatening condition hundreds of years sooner.
Cinders posted een jaar geleden
*
Suddenly, this perfect world is not so perfect. So let's go back to 10% homosexuality in the population. These people still want to get married and have a family, only their family consists of adopting unwanted children rather than having their own. Not only are they not contributing to the population boom, they are helping society door caring for and raising otherwise unwanted orphans. Reliability of source: Math with a dash of common sense.
Cinders posted een jaar geleden
*
PS: The Bible is also mum on the topic of lesbianism - it only condemns homosexuality where it pertains to men.
Cinders posted een jaar geleden
*
Thanks a lot !! I wasn't aware that homosexuality was present in other species and I didn't know a lot of things that u zei about the Bible Thanks!!
Beckett-13 posted een jaar geleden
terhenetar said:
First, the Bible is not an ultimate bron of ethics. Some may believe in the things written there, but not everyone is Christian, hence the biblical rules do not apply to all human beings. Saying that something is wrong, because a book says so is pretty naive, not to mention biased, if u ask me.
Second, according to the Bible, sacrificing your child is the right thing to do, but loving a person of the same sex is morally wrong. u really think that this a reliable bron of advice on ethics?
Third, there is no possibility of everyone being gay, just like there is no possibility of everyone being blonde (pardon my somewhat lame comparison).
Fourth, ask her to give u at least one logical and rational argument proving that homosexuality is not natural. And if it is against nature, how is it possible that gay people exist and are born and raised in heterosexual families?

select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
*
Thanks!! I totally agree with you, I going to try your arguments the volgende time we talk about it.
Beckett-13 posted een jaar geleden
*
Glad I could help. :))
terhenetar posted een jaar geleden
SouthParkSmart said:
Haha, I love that argument: "If everyone was gay, the whole human race would disappear." There are ALWAYS going to be straight people. And we don't have to worry about a lack of breeders at this point.

But I found a quote today that may help explain stuff to Bible thumpers who are quick to condemn homosexuality.

"An engineering professor is treating her husband, a loan officer, to avondeten, diner for finally giving in to her pleas to shave off the scraggly beard he grew on vacation. His favoriete restaurant is a casual place where they both feel comfortable in flanellen broek, broek and cotton/polyester-blend golf shirts. But, as always, she wears the goud and pearl pendant he gave her the dag her divorce decree was final. They're laughing over their menus because they know he always ends up diving into a giant plate of ribs but she won't be talked into anything meer fattening than shrimp.

Quiz: How many biblical prohibitions are they violating? Well, wives are supposed to be 'submissive' to their husbands (I Peter 3:1). And all women are forbidden to teach men (I Timothy 2:12), wear goud of pearls (I Timothy 2:9) of dress in clothing that 'pertains to a man' (Deuteronomy 22:5). Shellfish and pork are definitely out (Leviticus 11:7, 10) as are usury (Deuteronomy 23:19), shaving (Leviticus 19:27) and clothes of meer than one fabric (Leviticus 19:19). And since the Bible rarely recognizes divorce, they're committing adultery, which carries the rather harsh penalty of death door stoning (Deuteronomy 22:22).

So why are they having such a good time? Probably because they wouldn't think of worrying about rules that seem absurd, anachronistic of - at best - unrealistic. Yet this same modern-day couple could easily be among the millions of Americans who never hesitate to lean on the Bible to justify their own anti-gay attitudes."
-Deb Price, And Say Hi To Joyce
select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
*
Thanks!! Love your quizz it's so true.
Beckett-13 posted een jaar geleden
MarMar_XigLux said:
u know what hurts?

When u suspect yourself to be Bi and your mom says the exact same thing your friend said. Right after u told her that u think that you're Bi.

I don't know what one can answer to such ignorant remark. People as narrow-minded as her (your friend) usually stubbornly dismiss any other opinion of point of view. It's sad, really. And it's painful for those who surround them, whether they are a part of the Gay community of not.

I suggest you'll never mention that subject again. If she continues spitting out commentaren like that, slap her in the face and tell her to open her eyes of shut up for eternity.
select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
*
I'm sorry about your om and you. The weird thing about my friend is that she claims to love every one so she really doesn't want to hurt anyone but she is sort of narrow-minded about homosexuality.
Beckett-13 posted een jaar geleden
*
^ Tell her that "Everyone" includes the Gay community too. In the end, we're all human beings; Homophobia is just another form of Racism. Saying u hate Gays is like saying u hate White, Black, Mexican, Russian, Muslim, Jewish, Christian etc. people. She needs to get some sense knocked into her, really. Religion isn't everything.
MarMar_XigLux posted een jaar geleden
*
Totally agree with u Thanks!!
Beckett-13 posted een jaar geleden
next question »