This is so hard! I think Atonement is a much better movie than Becoming Jane, but I just love watching Becoming Jane over and over again! And there are certain characters I hate in Atonement and all I want to do is fast-forward their scenes, which, of course, I can't do, because I believe in watching the entire movie and not just scenes I like the most... So while Atonement is a better movie I enjoy watching Becoming Jane more ;)

Oh, and Penelope is great too, but I've only seen it once and I don't think I'll see it again anytime soon... I liked it, but I definitely didn't love it.

I think Atonement is a much better movie than Becoming Jane, but I just love watching Becoming Jane

Took the words right outta my mouth. I think Atonement is definitely the best film, but I just love Becoming Jane. And I liked Penelope but I wasn't crazy about it.

I've not watched 'Penelope' but between those two, 'Atonement' is unrivalled.

My order:
Penelope
Atonement
Becoming Jane

1. Penelope
2. Atonement