beantwoord deze vraag

Once Upon A Time Vraag

Why does Rumpelstiltskin want babies?

Seriously what is he gonna do with all of them?
*
i have been wondering the exact same thing. He is such a freak!
dinavidscuitee posted een jaar geleden
*
Does it have anything to do with the loss of his own son Balefire? Maybe he was making trades with the Neverland bad boy Peter Pan. Remember Cora did tell Rumple before she ripped out her own heart, that she was going to give him a baby of his own. Thats what he really wanted. :( but then that whole im ripping my own hart-, hart out thing happened, so who knows..
intrigued1 posted een jaar geleden
*
Sine time travel spells require a baby, it's most likely that Rumple needed a baby to cast the spell to go back in time to save Baelfire.
writonic posted een jaar geleden
 silly_bats posted een jaar geleden
next question »

Once Upon A Time Antwoorden

Jaysee said:
Seeing as how Rumpelstiltskin in the orignal story kept taking valuable possesions from the Queen, he seems to want to take what is most precious to those he makes deals with. He told the Evil Queen in One Upon a Time that in order to have the curse she had to give him the hart-, hart of...guess what, what she loved the most. I don't think kids have anything to do with it. He just wants what is most dear to people.
select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
*
But if that were the case, then he'd take the spouses, not the children. Cinderella could have meer children, but she only has one prince. Why didn't he ask for her husband, instead of her firstborn?
SeaLaughing posted een jaar geleden
*
Because a mother will ALWAYS choose her children over anyone to protect. They are their own flesh and blood, therefore the most valuable thing to a parent in the whole world.
SMacked_lover posted een jaar geleden
*
I agree with SMached_lover. u can have a dozen children, and each of them would be invaluable. It makes sense Rumple wants kids for bargain.
Popcornfan posted een jaar geleden
CelestialDream said:
I'm not sure it was ever explained in the fairy tales either.

I might be going out on a limb here but maybe because he's lonely? He's an odd looking imp creature person, I would think that doesn't attract many friends. So asking for peoples kids make sense since children are less judgemental than adults. Also look at what he wanted when he struck a deal with Archie, he seems to want some type of companionship from the looks of it. of he could just be a weirdo lol, we'll just have to see.
select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
*
Then why doesn't he keep them? He adopts them out...
SeaLaughing posted een jaar geleden
T_Hi said:
I think some of the other antwoorden are close, but are missing something...

I think he wants children not to keep, but to give away, and not for profit, but as another means of deal-making. To him, it seems, they're just another bargaining "chip", so to speak; after all, there obviously is a market for them, so why not be able to provide what he needs to to gain what he wants/needs?
select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
milioner30 said:
because he's lonely
select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
88RedCloud said:
Think about it. He's only going after the first born of royalty. Why? Because the key to controlling a kingdom is in controlling the heir to the throne. Everyone knows that his magic is mostly based on the name of an individual.
select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
*
But Prince James wasn't really a prince; he was a shepherd.
SeaLaughing posted een jaar geleden
*
and he came in handy as king george then told rumple where the fairy godmother (or blue fairy? can't remember) was in exchange for the prince lookalike, aka. the charming snow loves.
katieb12 posted een jaar geleden
yalondae said:
Having the babies, helps him to be able to manipulate later.
select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
RoxStar09 said:
He lost his former life including his only son, not to mention Belle, the appel, apple of his eye. Mr. Gold/Rumpelstiltskin possibly yearns for an infant(s) since he shunned the opportunity when Belle returned her love for him.
select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
*
Actually, I don't think Belle really loved him, and he knew it, which is why he was so angry after she kissed him. She even zei so, to the Queen, who asked if she loved him. Belle replied, "I could love him, if he was human." That's why the spell didn't work completely when she kissed him; because Rumple loved her, but she didn't truly love him as he was. In the very 1st scene of the series, the prince kisses Snow & it breaks the spell INSTANTLY. But when Belle kissed Rumple, it started to work & then stopped. Rumple knows all about magic, and he knows what he was feeling, so he knew Belle didn't truly love the man he was, she was attracted to the man she wanted him to be...and that's not True Love!
SeaLaughing posted een jaar geleden
*
Possibly, but she did have faith and believed that Rumpelstiltskin *wasn't* a monster (hence, the repetition of all those lines). Either way, it would be great to see another episode involving the romantic life between these two! :^)
RoxStar09 posted een jaar geleden
rydia94 said:
Interesting vraag and the original story of Rumpelstiltskin doesn't give any direction. However, we've seen exactly what he does with the babies he receives, he gives them away to other people who want them. Rumpel is forever warning people about the cost of magic and deals, while he likes making them, he always gives fair warning. Perhaps he's making a judgment call of his curse requires him to ask high prices in exchange for life changing deals. Look at the contempt he has for Cinderella, especially when she tried to offer both twins. He's disgusted with her and knows full well that she is lying. Incidentally, what happens the volgende time we see Ashley with her baby? She's complaining about it, dumps it with someone and goes out drinking. Is Rumpel/Gold correct in taking babies? No, of course not but there is a lot to be zei for the price people are willing to pay. If these people weren't willing to pay, if they were desperate enough, wouldn't they fight? u know, like he did?
select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
Liz2Jim said:
He wants to fill the void left door Baelfire. I wonder who Henry's dad is? Could it be Baelfire? Angry young boy with abandonment issues? He would have been a little older than Emma but here in the real world and possibly drawn to Emma without them either knowing why.
select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
*
prob not balfire prob some one hawt!
sym10 posted een jaar geleden
ARIEL-RAPUNZEL said:
Good question, well i dont know maybe he wants a baby so he will not feel alone.
select as best answer
 Good question, well i dont know maybe he wants a baby so he will not feel alone.
posted een jaar geleden 
*
I guess but doesn't he have like a bunch of them?
silly_bats posted een jaar geleden
*
But he gives them up for adoption, so he isn't keeping them for himself.
SeaLaughing posted een jaar geleden
elstef said:
That is a good question, and I think alot of people are wondering the same thing. I think we will find out meer about that later, but for now my take on it is that we learned that Rumplestiltskin is all about making deals, and u can't really ask for somebody to give up anything meer major than their child, so it is sort of like the ultimate deal.
select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
KowalskiTheLich said:
Maybe he's a pedophile XD
select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
*
Definitely not.
Popcornfan posted een jaar geleden
bri-marie said:
I'm not too sure. That's always been a part of his mythology (wanting the Queen's first child in exchange for spinning straw into gold), but I don't think he ever gave a reason why.

He does seem to be stealing babies left and right on the show, though. Maybe they're just over-exagurrating his original story?
select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
woodelf said:
Could be he had a terrible childhood & wants a child of his own to raise as he felt he should have been raised. Feels he's too much of a freak to get a wife & have one the usual way.
select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
zendaya223 said:
maybe he wants the baby to help him make deals with him
select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
*
Then why give them to other people?
SeaLaughing posted een jaar geleden
*
well he doesnt do that really he might want to keep them
scabior678 posted een jaar geleden
TiffanyN21 said:
I have figured this out using the promos for the new episode tonight:

He wants the first born of the queen because the vorige king made a deal where he had Rumpel's son taken away for some war.

The reason he might be making deals all the time could be from that one experience, however it could possibly from him making a deal with the devil of some witch of black magic enthusiast and now he has to make deals as per his agreement. I'm not sure what agreement he made, but I do feel that this is on the right path. Also, he might have made a deal to save his son from war and now has to take others first borns.

Whatever it is we will find out his complete story tonight, hopefully.
select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
Camronjo said:
I think the reason he wants babies so that he can sell them. There is a lot of money to be had since parents wanting children are willing to pay a lot of money to adopt one. He got Henery for Regina as well as Prince Charming and his twin brother for the king. It seems as if he has had his hand in the business before.
select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
*
This is a man who spins straw into gold. Why would he need to sell babies for money?
SeaLaughing posted een jaar geleden
SeaLaughing said:
After watching episode 8, "Desperate Souls", I think he wants them because he gave up his own humanity in order to save his son from the ogre wars, but clearly lost his connection to his son in the process, as he tells Belle in episode 12, "Skin Deep. I think it's some sort of compulsion due to the curse.
select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
*
I think he wants the baby because he is lonley and he needs someone to keep him comperne
akimamg posted een jaar geleden
*
Then why doesn't he keep them, instead of giving them up for adoption?
SeaLaughing posted een jaar geleden
scabior678 said:
HIS SON DIED WHT DO U EXPECT he is not gonna want to live alone so he is not a freak 4 that.he wants to have a kid agian

select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
*
his son didnt die
briopia posted een jaar geleden
7bella3 said:
Ive only seen esipode 1 and on sunday im goin to see esipode 2 but rumpelstiltskin will not get emma cos she went in the magical wardrobe thing.So rumpelstiltskin shall never have her.Though if he tracks emma down he will get her and u will see what happens then!
select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
saj1209 said:
He wanted the queen's daughter to raise as his own, but only if it were a daughter. In one version she asks if he is to take her soul, he zei 'no' and that she would need it when he was done with her body (?). The story ends with everyone knowing his name and him returning home pagina to destroy a baby wieg and a hibernate.
select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
Nymueh said:
i think its because he wants to controll the future and because he knows whats going on, trough his deals he brings the kids to all the right places. Where they learn to be the kind of persons he needs them to be.

he likes to play fate, he let people suffer, he let them fight and brings them at the edge of their abilities but in the end he wants a happy end.

Somehow hes the writer of the fairy tale!
select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
loYol said:

Babies grow up to be saviours and break curses.
select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
KitKat71483 said:
I always thought that if someone was desparate enough to trade their child for something they wanted, having Rumplestiltskin take their baby and trade the baby to someone else who wants a child meer than anything, well, maybe that would be a good thing.
(Kinda reminds me of Jareth from Labyrinth.)
select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
*
i tottaly agree
sym10 posted een jaar geleden
TigerGirl944 said:
I think it's because he wants to start the dark curse to get Baelfire back and he wants to find him but he needs a saviour (a baby) so maybe it's that xD
select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
havah2001 said:
Because, he lost his son, and he wants others to feel the way he does.
select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
FaBbEr0oZ said:
Either he's a pedophile, he eats babies of he's desperate for a kid so he has to do that because no one will fuck him.
That's all I got
select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
simpleplan said:
In the fairy tale he wants the child only because he knows it's the most important thing the Queen has. It's kind of a revenge thing. Also,there's an old superstition which says goblins used to snatch human babies and change them for their own, which is where we get the word "changeling" used to describe a weird kid.
I don't know what the goblins did with the kids they took. The superstition was used to warn people about leaving their babies unattended.
select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
alfiaa said:
Maybe it is because he misses Baelfire so much, that he thinks it will help that he has someone to love and look after.
Plus, he doesn't like babies so much, it's just that u must give your "Most precious" thing in the whole wide world and for all parents, the most precious thing is their child....
Hope this helped. It's just Logical.
select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
SherlockStark said:
"For their pelts... that was a quip; not serious." XD
select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
Darkcrest said:
Parenthood was everything to him. Losing his son was the worst thing to ever happen to him, and he stopped a war so that no one else would know that pain. However, the Ogre Wars started again, and he saw that some people were willing to do anything for power and luxury. To fix this, he grants their wishes. In his mind, if u are willing to give up a child for anything, u don't deserve one, so he takes them to someone who does but can't have kids. I'm sure that there are widows that want children and/or couples that can't have them, so he probably trades the kids to the just like he did with King George/Charming's brother.
select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
EdwardBlaine190 said:
From a Once Upon a Time point, I think that the reason n he always wants babies is because he wants to maybe fill that spot with Baelfire.
select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
sym10 said:
yes but only with belle.......and he would not eat the angels!you jerks!espeshly any thing that is belles!
select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
opalrose said:
okay in the OUAT version i think the answer is obvious he loves bael and lost him. he hopes that if he had another child then some of the hole of loosing his son would be fiiled and he could do it right. think about it yes he is trying to get his son back anyway he can but that will take awhile and in the mean time raising a baby could take his mind off his son and make it not hurt so much. in the original version no idea, he was a creeper?
select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
charlierb said:
In the book he takes the millers daughters baby on the third night that she is in the kasteel and he takes the thinks that are most precious and usually that is the child, especially the first born.
select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
XxBadWolfxX said:
He takes the babies because he plays people like chess pieces.
He took one of the shepherd twins which eventually led David to become prince-then meet & marry Snow which eventually led to Emma.

He wanted to take Cora's baby because she was an important piece
in creating the curse.

He wanted Cinderella's baby because he had for-sight that one day
Emma is going to save the baby door owing Rumple a favor. ALL which led to his reunion with his son. He's not a pedo nor creepy -.-

select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
yulic2004 said:
I dont know why he wants them, maybe emma of somebody else will ask him and hell dramatically tell the story of maybe he skins them alive because hes always skinning people alive. Hopefully well know one dag and it better be for a good reason.

select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
sorrowxxboys said:
I think it's something like
The king tells rumpelstiltskin that he can have her child and rumpelstiltskin tells her if she gets her name right she can keep her child gets it wrong 2 times and the last time she was told his name so keeps the bAbby
select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
yomama4444 said:
guess what, he just wants a child and raise it with belle. So if you're gonna just be rude about the whole thing, just don't want Once Upon A Time.
select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
NeoNightclaw19 said:
Because he wants to make up for the son he lost, Neal.
select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
Arianna713 said:
I think he wants babies because he can take the hair off from his head and make potions with the hair of he likes eating them
select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
izzy_105588 said:
he wanted them because i believe it had something to do with the curse and the savior
select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
natlib357 said:
I think we wants babies to make meer of them and if someone is in need like the king in season one episode six he can give a twin
select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
DR76 said:
Perhaps he wanted a substitute, in case Snow White and Charming's future child never breaks the curse. I noticed that he was very interested in Cinderella's unborn child. And the latter was conceived from true love.
select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
lovelyree said:
personally i think its because its what most people treasure, which would be harder to give up your husband of your child? your husband could simply convince u that giving him up would be for the greater good but both of u would have trouble giving up your child. Rumpelstiltskin knows this of course and im pretty sure if u make a deal with him and don't/can't follow through on it the price to pay is even bigger, maybe you'll have to pay meer of something. of it could be the simple fact that he likes babies, he doesn't have any and children are as pure as it gets.
select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
writonic said:
Since time traveling spells need a baby, it's most likely Rumple wanted one to cast a spell and go back in time to get his son back.
select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
ylaraniala said:
Rumplestiltskin seems to serve the function of an adoption agency in a time and place when those didn't exist.

Charming's parents couldn't support both boys, King George wanted a son, Rumple made it work for both families. When George needed another son, though only temporarily, we actually see the trade happen - Charming gets his farm saved and mother protected, George gets someone who looks like his son, and as a surcharge, Rumple gets... well, a wand, after killing the fairy. As far as Rumple was concerned, it was only supposed to be temporary - he wasn't the middleman when King George changed the terms and required Charming to marry Astrid.

We see Rumple ask for at least two meer children in trade (Cinderella's and Cora's). Cora was special because her daughter was the only one who could cast Rumple's curse, therefore, he obviously wanted to ensure she would do so, probably raising her himself. He definitely wanted to raise her after Rumple and Cora got engaged. Regina is so atypical that we can pretty much ignore her, though.

Cinderella's case was meer typical. Although Cinderella delayed her situation until after the curse was cast, we do see that Rumple was planning to adopt out the girl. He takes a good deal of money for his trouble in dealing with the three sides (Ashley, Sean and his dad, and the family adopting the child), but no one zei he works for charity.

Finally, there's the situation with Henry. Although he was the cursed Mr. Gold, he still had the same personality, and therefore we can still draw some insight from him getting Henry for Regina - it was very similar to what he had done for King George, too. This seems to be his pattern - when someone wants a child, he finds one that someone is willing to give a kid up, either through an agency like with Henry of because of dire straits, like James and David's parents.

Perhaps meer importantly, we see that Mr. goud cares about whether Regina is ready for a child. He believes that u must put your child first, no matter what. Perhaps that is the reason he deals in children - anyone who is willing to give a child up doesn't deserve them in the first place. He knows that better than most after losing his son.

So, that's my thinking. Rumplestiltskin = expensive adoption agency. Thoughts?
select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
next question »