i love neyton friendship but if there was no haley [no naley :(] then i'd be all for neyton again.
they're wayy different than when they were together 8 years ago

omg the thought of nathan without haley .... he's just not even nathan!
but brooke would be the best of these.
or maybe even possibly bevin? mia?
no, brooke.

Or with Peyton or Rachel. Actually Nathan would be cool with anyone... besides Carrie, Bitchtoria and Lindsey of course :P

i love neyton but if luke is still alive then i still love leyton! and brathan would be a cool couple!

I pick Brooke because Nathan and Peyton would just fight and drive each other crazy. Peyton should be with Lucas :d

I guess Brooke but I just can't imagine the show without Naley!!

luke's not alive either! sorry left that out of the question! :(

If there was no Haley then Nathan would be a total ass and so I'm fine with Peyton dating him.

Brathan all the way. I still think Lucas should be alive so we could have the hottest couples ever Leyton and Brathan!!!!

IDK why. They seem like they could work.
Plus, I think Brooke should be with Lucas, Peyton with Jake, and if Lindsey was with Nathan I can garuntee you she would be a better person :)

OMG, Brathan is like, my fantasy couple! (Don't get me wrong, I love Naley,b ut you know.. :p)
They would be soo hot and awsome together! :D

^^ yeah that would be interesting .... lindsey as a real person rather than just the bitch that took tore leyton apart (temporarily)!
wonder what she'd be like..?

misshenriken i'm right back you. I love Naley & Brucas, but Brathan is my fantasy couple. And they would be so HOT

im a total closet neyton fan! i know they fought in the past but that was before they both changed for the better and i think theyd be a really interesting couple. of course, im absolutely team leyton so in reality id be pissed...the question said that all of the girls were available tho, so whatever.

Brathan foreveer :D

Even though Brooke totally belongs with Lucas and Nathan with Haley....Brathan would be HOT!

If Haley Died Nathan would not want to be with any one else bacuse Haley ment everything to him

^ agreed


but if i absolutely had to pick, it would be Peyton

i always liked these two together.

ummm none cause if he wasnt with haley he should be with me!!!!