I loved it!
It was the SADDEST episode ending ever but I knew it was an AU episode and I really LOVED everything Chad wrote!
I think it was one of the best episodes till now..like it was interesting and included almost everythin of the show untill where it is now..DAN ROCKED..He's such a good evil man! LOL..And naley was all cute and "Always and Forever" and of course the main reason I LOVED it was because of Leyton..<333

All movies of that period are cheesy but still...that's why i don't like them! So there was that and the bad accents lol!

I dont like the fact that Luke called Peyton pretty girl...but the rest was pretty cool;)

Exactly I didn't like that he called her that either :P
But well this episode wasn't the best! Kind of boring acctually...

Just LOVED the Naley part<33

I think it was awesome!
Loved it!! CMM did a great job

CMM bravo!! well done great eppy..lovin leyton!!! <3

LOVED the Leyton scenes.... especially the end. but i didn't care so much for the episode as a whole. either way... for Chad's first time writing, i think he did pretty good

it was better than i could have ever imagined!!! naley was sooo CUTE!

I loved it. All of it, The Leyton and Naley was great...the "pretty girl" part though me a bit but then I remembered he Chad had said he took a bit from seasons past so I got over it but i know a lot of people didn't. The ending made me want to cry and Mouth getting tossed off the brige made me want to kill Dan myself but hey when don't I want to kill him? I still hated Julian even in the 40's! All and all if CMM wants to write more I'd be al for it!

loved it
chad michael murray hands down,because this episode was one of my favourites
i love all leyton scenesssssss

LOVED IT <333
It was amazing.. Chad did a fantastic jobs, one of my fave oth episodes probably. But it gets a 9 cos Peyton 'died' and the ending was scary!! (Peyton's stomach pains) EVEN IN A DREAM I HATED PEYTON DYING! lol

I really liked it but to be objective, there was a good deal of cheese so I can't say 9 or 10...

i actually really loved it i didnt know if i would or not but I DO!!!!!

It was corny, cheesy, unrealistic, not even historically correct, dumb, and they had Mouth and Peyton die!!! And, I blamed Mark earlier but I should be blaming Chad, CHAD decided to take brucas's signature line and use in on Peyton. :[

It was awesome!!! I think Chad is a very good writer, one of the best episodes of the season!!!

It was just way too corny. I mean Naley is my ALL TIME favorite character but when they are laying in bed together and talking about babies, I couldn't help but role my eyes.
I was really disappointed in Chad's writing I thought the dialogue was horrible.
Peyton came off as some nieve brat, which I don't think was how she was suppose to be.
I think I got my hopes up on this episode.

no sorry it was kinda bad