how did it suck?!:|
it ROCKED!

For the love of all that is...I want that hour of my life back. I love One tree hill but that was cheesy, badly acted by everyone but Bethany and Paul and the costumes sucked too. It was so ridiculously pointless and eugh, I feel dirty after watching.

nice icon addiee :)
I'm not surprised that some ppl thought it sucked, lol. It was chad's first episode though...anyhow I thought it was a good first effort on his part. Yes there was a good deal of cheese here and there, but I liked this vamped up version of OTH history. Chad unfortunately forgot to ACT, lol. but the idea of the episode was well thought. and there were some solid performances (Paul, Hilarie, Antwon, Joy, & Austin)...I actually watched it like 7 times already, lol. It's entertaining, hehe...

it was entertaining but the ratings for this episode is not good they were worse of the season.

Really Terra? poor Chad!
I think he did a good job!

he did good but the rating were 2.61 million viewers they have been just dropping. Hopefully next week will be great sense it is the last episode until January.

oh, okay:(
:O it is?? wow, we have to wait two months?? :O

i think so

I mean the naley was great and everything but it wasn't fabulous and it certaintly wasn't what I had anticipated.
It had A LOT of leyton as usual, so if you are a die-hard brucas fan you probably would have thought it was awful. And, on top of that, (and don't get me started on this because I could rant on it FOREVER) but Chad Michael Murray (I guess I can't blame Mark...) completely disgraced brucas!!! Jerk!
And it was very unrealistic and pretty corny. But, it had it's moments.

LOVED IT!

THE NALEY WAS GORGEOUS!

totally!!

JOKE JOKE JOKE

i was laffing at the end the acting was only decent by paul even joy who i totally love lacked and omg i hope peyton never dies jus so i dont have to see that joke of hilaries dieing scene

I take what I said back. It DID suck. I think livelovelaugh is pretty much right :]

i liked it. we gotten remember we're used to mark's writing and well this was chad's first try...i thought some of the writing in the beginning and the end were the scenes were current was kinda silly...stuff they wouldn't exactly say, especially peyton, but the story chad told was kinda cute...i thought the way he had naley get together was sweet and i think he did a good job with dan, and i think paul did a good job acting but of course i think paul is one of the better actors on the show to begin with. i couldn't really picture mouth as a drunk so that got me a little but i thought for a first time effort from chad it was pretty good. but i'm not surprised people didn't like it.

oh and i actually kinda thought it was entertaining how he totally brushed over brucas...hahaha actually made me laugh a little bit...and i still hated brooke which means he got her character pretty much right on really...hahaha

oh yeh he totally brushed over brucas haha that is sooooo funny

it didn't suck & Leyton were GREAT <3

GAH. NOT ABOUT LEYTON VS BRUCAS, although yes the pretty girl thing in the beginning was harsh even leytoners have to admit that, IT WAS ABOUT THE SUCKYNESS OF THE EPISODE. One more leyton vs brucas comment and I will NUKE the set of OTH, I love the show but just to make it stoppp.

haha great idea lol

Awww poor Brucasers LMFAO!!!

i loved it! it was funny, entertaining, i thought it would be crappy so ... =P
not to shabby.

Way to corny (leyton and naley parts)
Horrible writing
Horrible acting(CHAD!)
Liked hearing Bethany singing and enjoyed the 40s theme.

Wow, you're all so nice!! (Note the heavy sarcasm.)
Chad MEANT for it to be corny, like most other 40's movies/ TV shows. Chad admitted he was so nervous about the episode that his acting wasn't great. And as for the writing, I thought it was great, but for those of you who didn't I'd love to see you write a better episode. Actually, I wouldn't. It would suck. Seriously, stop being such picky brats. If you don't like the show, stop watching and stop complaining all the time!

for mpst people this is the first time they have ever complaineed about the show ya can dislike some episodes ya no

This was Chad's first episode! Don't be to harsh on him and the acting, cause first of all, they've never played like it's 1940. Second of all, how realistic can a dream really be? It was a DREAM. And three, I totally agree with leyton_love! It's MEANT to be corny, didn't you know it is 68 years between 1940's and 2008?
I don't wanna seem bitchy or anything, I understand why some of you picked yeah!

I loved it, it was nice to have a change of OTH. Still some more drama but it was amazing. Leyton was freakin awesome and so was Naley. Julian looked really good, and Dan;s mustache was awesome.