ummm it would really depend though on which time they were fighting

cuz in the beginning when nathan was being all mopey in his wheelchair i kinda agreed with haley...but then later in the season i agreed more with nathan.........

I think Haley was being real irrational and judgemental . That`s what I hate about her because that`s how she`s always is . She judges people so much before stepping back and looking at her own mistakes .

During the beginning when Nathan was all depressed and in that wheelchair I was on Team Haley but after he straightened up and the whole thing happened with Psycho Carrie I was on Team Nathan even though I understood Haley's reasons...Nathan wasn't at fault...at least not the way Haley was acting like it was...I'm just glad they worked it out and now their fine!

I agree with Myra, sometimes Haley is way too judgmental. What Nathan did with Carrie was what she had done with Chris Keller, and at least Nathan WAS gonna tell her about it. Carrie just "got" him first.

And i still can't believe it that she asked him a divorce, when Jamie had almost died!

lmao i already told you guys this ^ sort of. my haley hating days (:

same reason as the others :P

haley ; ]

I love Haley but Nathan really didn't do anything wrong and if you look back on season 5, Nate was about to tell Haley everything when Carrie walked in and announced she had to quit due to another job oppurtunity(looks misspelled, sorry). Yeah he wathched Carrie swim naked but it was only for a sec and if you noticed the look on his face, he was shocked not turned on.

Poor guy she wouldnt even listen to him :(
But he had done some asshole moves lately, idk its so hard, I love them both and cant choose sides, idk

But when Nathan gets that sad look in his eye i cant help but forgive him and love him !