Keep in reminder that it is a "if" question

I really don't!!
If she tells peyton...then idk if that will go well...Look at what happen when peyt confess her feeling to brooke.
If she Keep it a secret from evreybody..that won't help since it will come out anyway.
If she tells lucas right away...Then well idk how luke will react..probably just say.."Oh"..lol
So really don't know!?!?!

I agree with what Leytonfan4ever said, but she should not tell Lucas right away.

peyton would go easy on brooke cuz she knows how it is to be in that position & they`re best friends . though I doubt lucas would really care .

on one part i do agree with you Lila856 about telling peyton first but i STRONGLY desagree that lucas wont care.I'm not saying that he'll say "i love you too" but i dont think he'll just throw her away and how brooke feels

if brooke were to tell peyton, I don't think peyton would react as crass as brooke did. obviously it would complicate things. anyhow, I sure hope it doesn't happen. brucas had their try...in all FOUR seasons...they don't work!

i think she should tell lucas right away cause if she keeps it bottled inside it wont be good for her or him

if that happens she HAS to tell Peyton first cause if she doesn't it could get messy, you know the same thing as before but the roles would be switched lol! Or a slap around the other way!

do what peyton did to her.
Tell her BFF she is in love with her BF.
what goes around, comes around, right?


but to be honest... if peyton hadn't told brooke about her feelings for lucas, i would have picked for brooke not to say anything and just try and forget it... exactly what peyton SHOULD have done.

HE IS NOT EVEN GOING OUT WITH PEYTON IN SEASON 5 HE IS GOINGOUT WITH SOMEON ELSE SO YEAH SHE SHOULD ASK HIM STRAIGHT HIM AWAY

BRUCASA 4 EVER AND ALWAYS I LOVE THEM I HATE LEYTON THEY SUCK

should tell her first then lucas

i don't think she'd tell peyton....or she might get a slap too..hehe....she can tell lucas but only if the situation is right...don't want my fav character getin dissed by lucas for that matter...

TELL EM STRAIT UP
BRUCAS FOREVA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!!­!!!­!
I HATE LEYTON SO MCH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Brooke would know how peyton felt when it was her in this postition - i dont think peyton would even abondon brooke like brooke did to her! if brooke did tell lucas how she felt what makes you sure that lucas feels the same way?
aswell peyton wasnt going to tell lucas she only decided to tell him when she knew for certain brucas were broken up infact she waited till after lucas and brooke decided they didnt love each other the way whitey loved camilla!
Brooke should do the same in that situation.
it doesnt matter anyway its not like theres gunna be a brucas again.
LEYYTTOONNN FFOORREEVVEERR - BRUCAS NEVVERR!!!

I dont see Brucas ever happening. Brooke loves Lucas as a friend and thats it. I see Chase coming back for her because in that one episode they seemed to still have feelings for each other. I also read he was on set with brooke for one of the upcoming episodes. And its obvious that Lucas does not have romantic feelings for Brooke. He loves Peyton. I also dont think Mark the producer would put Sophia back with Chad because I think it would hurt her too much. And Brooke wouldnt do that to Peyton. And LP is endgame.

karma bitch ;D