i mean come on....seriously

They're all unrealistic, but relatable.

I think they all have their unrealistic aspects. I think Haley & Brooke's parents being MIA during their high school years is EXTREMELY unrealistic lol. Teenagers don't just live by themselves, and raise themselves at that age...

But I guess I'll go with Peyton, just because of the never-ending tragedy that she went through. Losing both of her moms, being shot, being attacked twice, life-threatening pregnancy... it's just an awful lot for one person to take on.

Nathan:
-Emancipated when he was 16.
-Married when he was 16
-He had three car accidents
-He was practically done with basketball and then he comes back and plays in the NBA.
-He married again while he was in HS.

But, all of them have really unrealistic storylines. No everybody have a clothing line when they're in HS, or go on tour, or produced cds. For me, it's between Nathan and Peyton. And you're right, Brooke, Haley and Peyton practically raised themselves.

^ Yeah you're right, I guess Peyton counts too as far as her parents not really being around. And I didn't even think about Naley getting married in HS... that's definitely unrealistic as well!

ALL OF THE ABOVE.....lol These kids have gone through so much during their teen years/young adult years,its ridiculous! But for some reason Haley being a rockstar always sticks out to me the most.
She was valedictorian of her senior class.
She got married at 16 to the star basketball player.
She had a baby with her husband at age 18 during graduation.
Her parents during most of her teen years? MIA
She got her own apartment.
She went on a rock tour at 17...
She is married to a former NBA player.
She has been very successful in the music business.
She now runs a label.
She taught an English class while helping a student in her class get fostered.
Her best friend is a published writer and one of her close friends is a fashion designer/creator of the brand B.Davis.
......Peyton Sawyer is the obvious choice but for some reason Haley's life always puzzled me.That girl is academically and musically gifted? lol :)WHAT A LIFE!

okay maybe 1 of these things can happen to you but not all of them in 6 years :/
you wouldnt even have any freetime.

For all the reasons Dansea08 said.


Love Haley! But yeah... hers is super unrealistic.

Petyon with her stalker
Brooke with her clothing line
Nathan with the marrying at 16, emancipation and NBA
Lucas was probably the most realistic.

I agree with Kelly (:

Peyton's storylines are the more unrealistic but the most entertaining & interesting IMO.
But getting married at 16 and open you're own fashion design is not something you see everyday.