I need help finding a new show!

I have NO idea what toon to recommend, you've named all of them. :D lol

I think u might enjoy LOST :D Lost is awesome. Not full of relationship-dramas and with a lot of "puzzles". It gets quite confusing but I enjoyed how it made me think about stuff and how things were connected =)
And Malcolm in the middle, because if u enjoy Scrubs and TBBT, you'll enjoy Malcolm in the middle. Rizzoli & Isles might interest u too, it goes meer into the "crimes" direction. ;)

WOW. this is gonna be hard. u and i have very similar taste. and we share a lot of the same shows. lols. though i find it weird that u like er but not greys, i find them quite a like.
anyways moving on,
well i strongly recommend modern family its hilarious, (if u love comedies, this is a must see)
and seeing as u watch HIMYM, u should probably watch vrienden they are pretty alike. and if u like vrienden u probably like cougar town. (all somewhat alike, just different settings)
as for drama, u already watch mnost of the shows i watch except NCIS, though i have to warn u abt NCIS, dont watch all at one shot, can be very boring, cause it a lot to digest. but if u watch bit door bit, it really good. the relationships on the shows are interesting.
after that, i really have no idea what u should watch. may the other spin offs of csi?? lols. i really have no clue.
u can also try going to FOX.com, cbs.com abc.com, nbc.com, etc to look at new shows. and looking at what u dislike, avoid the cw network.
Have fun!:D

Maybe u could try Dollhouse, it has an interesting plot in my opinion. It has ended now and it has only two seasons!You could see the Pilot and decide for yourself.
I definetely recommend Lost, but u have probably heard about it/watched it.
Also if u like thrillers u could try Harpers Island.