Andy was there third time, im sure he deseved it much more than Roger to his collection...Im sure Federer know what Im talking about cos of his Roland Garros finals exect this year one...

When a match is that close, it's not fair to say that one deserved it more than they other. It really could have gone either way. I just think Roddick got tired and Federer took advantage of that in the end. Otherwise I don't think you could seperate them. I don't think Federer played a particularly great game, but then you could arguew that's because Roddick was playing so well.
I'm pleased Federer could win his 15th grand slam though.

Andy really deserved. After all Federer won like 5 Wimbledons.

Not saying Federer didn't deserve it, but it made me really sad to see Andy come so close. :( I thought with the amazing tournament he was having, he deserved it just as much or more as Roger did, especially after beating Murray! Federer has already beaten Andy in a final.. like three times? it would've been cool to see Andy finally beat Roger!

Not saying that Fed didn't deserve it, because if anyone puts that much effort in, then they deserve to win. But I love Andy .... me and my mom were heartbroken ;( There is just something like sorta mechanical, I guess, about Feds playing. Sometimes you really can't see the passion in him that other players put into the game with him. No wild saves, killer serves, and I really think that that is way more entertaining when you see someone really play with their whole heart.