Hmm.. i just wna kno ure opinions on this!!

No I dont think it would, because their personalities are totally different, and kind of goes along with what they are. Like Jake is so friendly and warm and stuff, and Edward is meer reserved and intense and stuff. I dunno I just think there wouldnt be a story lol, because I dont think Jake would leave the way that Edward did, just because of his personality.
And also, can u imagine a furry Edward? LOL, me neither ;)

I don't think it would work...

I mean, being a vampire is a huge part of Edward - after being a gentleman of course. But - for me, he's so attractive because he's so dangerous at the same time. Yeah, werewolfs are dangerous too, but in a different way. Only when they get really mad, for a vampire it's not getting mad, it's being close to someone he want. ... of something ;)

I kinda think that`s completely impossible, meaning their whole characters have been built upon the core understanding of the difference between vampires and wolfs. Our complete acceptance of them both stands upon knowing they are what they are-for Edward especially-we know from the start he is a vamp and we never think of him as something else. So if you`re asking whether Bella`s choice would be different is Jacob was the vamp, I would say-no-she didn`t choose Edward,`cause he`s a vamp, she chose him because they were meant to be!

it defo wudnt work!! cos, u can so tel frm the way edward acts nd talks tht he is waaayyyy olda thn jacob.

I think it would be kinda werid i mean u cnt rly c rob as a werewolf n plus jacob is hot we shouldnt change him lol...=)