No, I agree. Catherine did do a good job with Twilight but Chris was almost perfect. He kept as much from the book as he could fit, and 97% of everything in there was in the book, and the 3% were things that are at least fit with something the charactors would have said. I loved it, and the only thing I don't really like is the frolicking scene, but Chris regrets that scene, too. But hey, with how great the rest of it was, I can accept that. Twilight was good, but there were SO many things left out that I miss dearly, that could easily have been fit in instead of scenes that she just made up. For example, if she had cut out the Waylin diner, death, and police station scene (or even one of them) then we could have had our TRUE meadow scene. It was completely differant in the movie than the book.
Movie of book Twilight was way better cause New Moon the book was totally boring and the movie was way off compared to the book and the Twilight movie was really similar cause it was a female director and she consulted Stephenie through the whole movie plus the book was great too.
No, you're not. I think that New Moon is better, because Jacob had a meer important role here than Edward. And I'm definetly team Jacob. He's so cute, hot and the perfect best friend and boyfriend, too. :)