I don't think that he'd want her to be with either of them to be honest! I mean, if I found out that my daughter was dating a werewolf or a vampire I'd be pretty pissed and try and get her as far away from him as possible!

But then again, Charlie should at least try to see that Edward makes her very happy ... and if he could (which he probably couldn't!) look past the fact that he is a vampire ... which is totally ridiculous.

Mainly because she never disappeared for days when she hung out with Jacob.
Jacob would have described himself as a "protector"

Well he does eventually find out Jake is a wolf but I also think once Bedward are married he's fine with everything