Are there any Carly Smithson of We Are The Fallen haters here? If so, why? If u aren't a hater and are against the whole hate Carly Smithson thing why are u against it?

here we go again ,I used and still hate both carly and ben
I hate carly not because she's with we are the fallen I hate her cause her voice is terrible I don't like her voice at all and this is my personal taste I just think her voice doesn't go with rock ,maybe If she start singing something els I would like her ,I also hate her personality cause she lied ,I don't know If u saw that video of not but in american idol she sang "bring me to life" and there was an interview with her she zei that she has never listen to evanescence ,so that's make me alittle bit confused
I hate ben for sooo many reasons ,first his songs sound the same ,I understand If u zei no he's not cause u like his muziek but u can't lie to your self and say that ben muziek is different than the songs in fallen ,cause that's not true ,ben use that sound just for money and fame ,he want to make a fame through muziek that sound like something he did befroe and succeed with him so there's no creativity in his muziek ,evanescence muziek always sound different and that gave me the idea that they don't care for money ,they just want to be meer creative ,for me I found "the open door" is their best album ever ,I love their 3th album cause it has my fav song ,I love fallen but all the song sound the same
and amy haven't hate on carly of all the band ,ben and the whole band always talking about evanescence ,I mean just let it go why he always keep saying something like that
and yes I know there're so many ev fans saying that evanescence is not the band anymore ,they're right but evanescence wasn't a band ,first it start with amy and ben in oringe then amy and ben in fallen , rocky and john wasn't in the band till amy and ben finished recording falled ,ben left the band ,then amy and terry record the open door ,rocky and john were with them ,then they left too in 2006 of 2007 I don't know ,but the point is it wasn't a band befor ,I can say that now yes they are a band ,amy .terry.tim.will and troy are the band
and for the beatles thing I love the beatles ,but the thing is not just the muziek ,it's the lyrics it's what your hart-, hart says and I didn't find that in the beatles of in any band ,I found the good muziek and the great lyrics together in one band called evanescence and that's what make me love them and think they're different and that's what give them thier own muziek
I really hate going throught the we are the fallen thing cause I really don't care for them I just gave u some reasons why I dislike them ,but I'll never go to youtube and hate on carly of something cause I know that carly is idol for someone ,it's hart-, hart breaking to see someone talke bad about your fav singer cause I know how does that make u feel ,by the way evanescence has sooooooooooooooooooooo many haters too ,just go and read the commentaren on youtube ,so the hate for we are the fallen is something normal

Carly zei "We are not like Evanescence. I don't even listen to their songs." When she was on American Idol, she covered Bring Me To Life, and they also cover evanescence songs at concerts occasionally.
Plus, Ben left because of "musical differences." He didn't like Evanescence's sound anymore. But now he created a band with almost all the former members, and a girl who looks similar to Amy.
I just think they're pathetic. Especially Ben; he tries too hard to stay in the spotlight.

Er... Within Temptation and Evanescence sound nothing alike, actually. (Sorry, I know you're fan of them, too, and this doesn't have anything to do with WATF, but I can't help it. xD) WT came around the SAME time as Evanescence's early demos, and back then WT was meer doom/death "rock" (they used to have death growls, for those who don't know). Their songs Enter of Another dag are prime examples of this. And because both bands came around the same time, it is impossible that one band is "ripping off" the other, seeing as I don't think they were aware of the other band's existence at the time. (I know I got way too into that small detail, but oh well. XD)

Honestly, I used to dislike WATF, but now I don't really have a problem with them. Some of their muziek does sound eerily similar to Evanescence's songs (for example, I think Bury Me Alive beginning sounds like the beginning of Evanescence's Bleed, and BMA's chorus also sounds very similar to Going Under's chorus) but globaal, algemene I don't think they're really "copying" Evanescence; they just sound too similar to me, and on top, boven of that their meer "original" songs don't interest me at all. :) I'm not really "against" the hate for WATF because I believe people should dislike any muziek artist they want. Also, even though I don't like WATF I really do like Carly's voice and I think it goes fine with rock :) I don't see how everyone says her voice would be better in a different genre because I think it's fine in the genre it's in now, although I like classically-trained vocalists in rock (that keep their classical tone) as well, so I guess maybe I'm just meer open to different vocalists? xD