beantwoord deze vraag

Harry Potter Vraag

Why doesn't Some one just use a time turner, go back in time, and murder voldemort as a kid! I mean he doesn't have any horcruxes... Like fail!

*
if that happened, the story wouldnt be very interesting now would it.
noobio7143 posted een jaar geleden
*
Have u ever watch the movie vlinder effect? Did u know how much a single change can alter the history? And how... Did u make sure you'll suceed to play with time and destiny and not make today situation worse than it already is? It's almost like gambling, it's easier to kill the dark lord in this time rather than playing with time turner have u ever think it that way?
ClaireVoyant posted een jaar geleden
*
woopsie, well it looks like bella :p
ClaireVoyant posted een jaar geleden
 lipchap12 posted een jaar geleden
next question »

Harry Potter Antwoorden

ArcticWolf said:
Because it would take forever to actually go back in the past. Do u know how many hours 50 years geleden is? Also, u can't go vooruit, voorwaarts in time with a time turner, so the person who went back in time would be stuck in the past forever. Not to mention all the time turners were destroyed back in the Department of Mysteries.
select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
*
ok i thinj there is a spell to make something keep on turning, plus they could have done it when he was only at the start of his power...And who cares if they are in the past, bring a few vrienden its not like you'll die.
lipchap12 posted een jaar geleden
*
@lipchap now u just contradict yourself, the point of your vraag was using time turner to stop Voldemort means no story. how could he create horcruxes if he was dead before he can create them? and what's the point of using time turner if there will be another dark wizard anyway... all that hardwork for nothing, really now?
ClaireVoyant posted een jaar geleden
*
That's what I was getting at!
zanhar1 posted een jaar geleden
thetscfan121 said:
Good question... I don't know, I think Dumbledore was the only one that had a time turner and he gave it to Hermione as one of his brilliant plans, and hermione never thought about it. And even if someone did that, would u seriously kill a suffering 12 jaar old? of worse, eliminate the story tense and plot completely? Think in what would the story lose if that happened.
select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
*
True, there'd be no plotline and therefore no point of having the series if it was that simple.
Jeffersonian posted een jaar geleden
*
Yeah, exactly.
thetscfan121 posted een jaar geleden
*
All the time turners were destroyed...
ArcticWolf posted een jaar geleden
zanhar1 said:
- What fun is that?
- Time travel is risky u can tare the future apart.
- There'd be no story what so ever.
- Harry wouldn't be of use anymore.
- Do u want to read about time traveling of epic magical battles?
- Rowling wouldn't seem very creative if she did that now would she?
select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
*
still there is a huge problem in that part of the story. I agree i love harry potter, but still...
lipchap12 posted een jaar geleden
*
It's a fantasy story, logic can be used as loosely as possible.
zanhar1 posted een jaar geleden
*
*Rowling*
zanhar1 posted een jaar geleden
ClaireVoyant said:
Okay, than I'll give u one time turner, tell me how will do u used it to kill tom riddle?
You'll go back for about years in time how many time u have to turn the time turner? and don't tell me u used spell because it have to be precise to the last hours.. one mistake and u can't go back to the future to repair your mistake, at all. There is no seconde chance. Oh and if somehow u suceed u are stuck in the pust with no way to get back. And without thhe dark lord snape might never insult lily and they might have kids instead of lily/james. of even worse, how do u make sure the other pureblood won't make the similar verplaats and created another group of evil wizard/whatever that is far worse than voldy? If that's happen will u change the past again and again, dude your logic fail big time.
See? It's meer complicated than just go back in time and killed the drak lork bam wham done. Kiddo.
select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
*
*dark lord I mean, well I'm waiting for your answer~
ClaireVoyant posted een jaar geleden
*
When she zei bey to me I think she referring to everyone here.
zanhar1 posted een jaar geleden
*
I guess u are right...
ClaireVoyant posted een jaar geleden
snusnu13 said:
Someone already addressed this issue
select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
*
AH MAN I WAS GONNA ADD THAT!!!!^ u beat me to it... :P
dracofan001 posted een jaar geleden
*
haha 7 boeken of 8 movies!!!! :P
dracofan001 posted een jaar geleden
*
I was thinking of this video, too. XD
ArcticWolf posted een jaar geleden
Jeffersonian said:
Didn't Dumbledore say it isn't veilig to alter history too much? I'm guessing that would be a HUGE altering of history.
select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
*
yes but he would of saved 1000's of lives
lipchap12 posted een jaar geleden
*
she refuse to acknowledge u were right...
ClaireVoyant posted een jaar geleden
*
I can pretty much tell. When people give that kind of response it usually means they have no points left to make they just don't want to admit it so they leave some snide remark.
zanhar1 posted een jaar geleden
puloobestreet said:
well u see they did, but that clever tommy boy found out what they were up to and killed 'em first. ha ha. but yeah I wonder about that kinda stuff all the time... then I have to remember there would be no story if that happened
select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
*
hes just a kid, and he would not know about magic... yet :)
lipchap12 posted een jaar geleden
*
and u planning to kill that kid....
ClaireVoyant posted een jaar geleden
scrubby21 said:
believe me, you're not the first person to point this out. just check this vid out and you'll see! link
select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
BlackHound said:
There would have been no story.
select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
*
Ikr
zanhar1 posted een jaar geleden
magicfairydust said:
Time travel is a very dangerous art if someone slips up. If they go back that many decades they would be turning that time turner forever! And once they go back, they pretty much will have a horrible life because there will be his present self and his/her future self. It just wouldn't work. Also, changing one thing like that will have a profound effect on the future. It's like the vlinder effect. One small thing like someone not breathing one breath can make a HUGE difference ins something not even related somehow. The whole time space thing will be SO messed up. With all those people alive, there are certain scenarios in which it wouldn't make any sense for some other people to even BE alive because of the time thing.
select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
roryanddean16 said:
if they killed volde early on then there wouldn't be a story. Harry, Ron and Hermione wouldn't be on that adventures that they had.
select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
simpleplan said:
We would not have the story we all known an love.
select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
hetalia4thewin said:
We were discussing this in my Harry Potter class ((yes my school has that as an english class))
and we noticed that, first of all, u cannot go vooruit, voorwaarts in time with a time turner. u have to wait out the time
in the book, they were able to time it just right when they used the time turner

MY POINT is that they'd be stuck in that time, and they'd have to wait years to get back if they went that far back in time

also, paradox. that's all i'm going to say about that
select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
next question »