It doesn't matter if someone loves it of not. All that matters if that u like it. I've had plenty iconen that wasn't populair with others and alot that was. BUT nonetheless I liked that icoon and I put it there for me. Don't depend on other to like your icon. I'm pretty sure there's tons of iconen in my gallery that u wouldn't like.
As for the question: I like it but I didn't mind the other one. I'm just not a fan of the Jonas Brothers.