What do you think? Place your vote!
(Placed your vote already? Remember to login!)

Hetalia Couples! Do pairings have to be historically accurate? ( I think not )

76 fans picked:
No, let people ship whatever they want to ship....
No, let people ship whatever they want to ship. It's not about the yaoi.
   54%
It depends.
It depends.
   18%
Does it matter?
Does it matter?
   17%
Yes. They have to be historically accurate of else...
Yes. They have to be historically accurate of else I won't ship it. (Oh ._.)
   11%
 FlyingTurtle posted een jaar geleden
Make your pick! | next poll >>
save

31 comments

user photo
No, let people ship whatev- er...
FlyingTurtle picked No, let people ship whatever they want to ship. It's not about the yaoi.:
I don't want arguments here but, I think people should ship whatever they want.
Some people prefer the Hetalia pairings to be shipped as people, some history may offend others.
A lot of people are tired of seeing pairing bashing all over the place.
Those who ship characters because of the history, I do not mind if you ship it for the history but please do not bash those who ship characters as people. (Like they look good together, etc.)
Just please don't bash.
Ahem, now, onto the other fandom I'm in.
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
Yes. They have to be...
pumpkinqueen picked Yes. They have to be historically accurate of else I won't ship it. (Oh ._.):
If you are shipping them as people, then you are just turning the characters into OCs, something they are not. They are not people, they are the countries. That is a heck of a lot more offensive then using them as what they really are, the countries. So stop using stupid headcanons that screws up the series and characters. I find it a lot more offensive when you don't use history. It's insulting to the countries if you don't care enough to think about it. How can people find their history offensive? That is stupid as heck.

There is no sense in shipping to countries that have no history or good history. That is more insulting then anything. Would it make sense to support America with Cuba? Or S.Korea with N.Korea? God no! And turning them into people isn't any better. Heck, even more insulting that way.

It makes me sick when this side of the fandom doesn't care enough about history to even look before they ship. If you actually got out of your stupid headcanons and stopped turning the characters into your on OCs, and actually READ history. maybe you'd actually understand Hetalia more, get more respect for it, the pairings, and the characters.
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
No, let people ship whatev- er...
FlyingTurtle picked No, let people ship whatever they want to ship. It's not about the yaoi.:
Ohhhhh, somebody is mad.
I also do know my history and I do not make the characters my ocs. (why would I make them my ocs? ._.)
Did you know Himaryua encourages the fans to make headcanons, ocs, pair whoever with whoever and other fan made things? I think you don't know that. It seems like youre not allowing the fandom to things that they enjoy doing.
I find it offensive when someone pairs England or France with a native version of America or Canada. I'm not listing my reasons or else I would get carried away. :I
I'm also not here to argue with you so... Yeah. I'm not replying.
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
Yes. They have to be...
pumpkinqueen picked Yes. They have to be historically accurate of else I won't ship it. (Oh ._.):
If you are changing the characters into humans, something they are not, then yes you are making them OCs. Not using canon reasons and history is insulting. Not only the countrise, but the series. It's pointless and stupid to only 'love' something for looks. It shows how shallow the world is now.

If you had any respect for the countries, characters, and the series. You wouldn't do those things. ANy fan should know that. It's not right, and it's actually pretty rude. Makes you look like you don't respect the characters for how they were created.

UsUk and Franada are insulting, because the countries don't have good relationships. And in Hetalia the relationships are clearly just family. I find it insulting when people pair America with countries that doesn't have a good relationship with them.
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
No, let people ship whatev- er...
FlyingTurtle picked No, let people ship whatever they want to ship. It's not about the yaoi.:
If you don't like my own opinions, please be quiet.
I do not want to argue with you anymore, well I never wanted to argue but all I'm doing is defending the fans who ship whatever. Most of the fans who ship crack and non-historical pairings are not weebs at all, heck they even respect the country and do research. (Well those fans are mainly on tumblr, multifandom side of youtube, and pixiv)
But whatever, you're probably too pissed off and taking Hetalia too seriously to understand what I'm talking about.
Good day to you. ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
Yes. They have to be...
pumpkinqueen picked Yes. They have to be historically accurate of else I won't ship it. (Oh ._.):
You're a shallow piece of sh*t fan. You have zero respect for Hetalia, because if you did you wouldn't be doing that. Why don't you try taking something serious for once. Instead of being a shallow idiot, and disrespect the characters by turning them into OCs and drooling over stupid pointless fanart/smut. 'fans' like you are an insult to this fandom. You don't support anything, those aren't even pairings. All you like is the fanservious people feed you. You just want your smut and eye candy. People like you are the ones who go around calling France a rapist and Spain a pedo.
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
Does it matter?
videogamergirl picked Does it matter?:
It's an ANIME. holy shit...it's not REAL life love. it's a friggin japanese cartoon. ppl need to grow up. Either that or they're VERY obsessed with history to care that much. What about other anime's with NO history preference at all? it doesn't matter then so why now with this anime? Think about that...
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
Yes. They have to be...
Ninano1998 picked Yes. They have to be historically accurate of else I won't ship it. (Oh ._.):
WOW. the ignorance continues. pumpkinqueen you know what i realized. These people need their yaoi for they have no life. You people, videogamegirl & FlyingTurtle, stare at pictures of OCS and thats it. You have no respect for anything hetalia is truly offering and are to oblivious to the actual lessons it tries to teach. So its in a anime form, ever consider that may be this is a way that our countries want us to understand out culture? no you people are jokes, Go back to school. Maybe then you'll finally take into account what you learned and apply it. Still don't get it? well let me sum it down for you kids.
how would you feel if -i don't know- you were a american yet your father was an immigrant from england and all you friends kept telling you you and your FATHER should hook up. THats not alright. You assholes like incest? well what the fuck is wrong with you. If you like it go to your own parents and do it with them. I view hetalia as an amazing opportunity to get people a little more involved with history, not to go OC-ing it.

How was that as an easy explanation?
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
No, let people ship whatev- er...
FlyingTurtle picked No, let people ship whatever they want to ship. It's not about the yaoi.:
Oh... That was rude.
Whatever, you two. Go ahead and think that.
I'm done with the whole fandom. There was a girl who was bullied for making a France joke and another girl got bullied by fans for shipping a certain pairing. :I
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
Yes. They have to be...
pumpkinqueen picked Yes. They have to be historically accurate of else I won't ship it. (Oh ._.):
FlyingTurtle: Good, we don't need idiots like you in this fandom. Frankly, you aren't even a fan of it. You don't care at all about it. You want your OCed Yaoi, that's it.
And the France 'joke' thing. If it was a 'joke' about rape. Then good. She needed a good slap in the face. Because there is nothing funny about those types of 'jokes' So go back to your insulting disrespect filth and jokes about rape all day long. But stay the hell away from this fandom.
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
Yes. They have to be...
Ninano1998 picked Yes. They have to be historically accurate of else I won't ship it. (Oh ._.):
Damn straight
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
No, let people ship whatev- er...
StanTheMan432 picked No, let people ship whatever they want to ship. It's not about the yaoi.:
pumpkinqueen and Ninano1998, I think you guys are the only two historical fangirls who actually make a big deal out this. I personally think it doesn't matter. It's an anime. No I am NOT ignorant or stupid. And yes, I DO respect Hetalia just as much as the next person. Just leave ppl alone. You are nothing but trolls.
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
No, let people ship whatev- er...
RockerGirl333 picked No, let people ship whatever they want to ship. It's not about the yaoi.:
wooowww....43%! that proves that no one really cares about the history part of their pairings only the personality.
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
No, let people ship whatev- er...
FlyingTurtle picked No, let people ship whatever they want to ship. It's not about the yaoi.:
The girl who made the joke understood what she did and apologized yet she got death threats and was cyberbullied.
and you support that? Good, I'm glad not to be in the same fandom with a fan who takes everything seriously and judges those who do whatever they want. I used to take hetalia seriously, but then I realized its just a anime.
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
No, let people ship whatev- er...
T045tToastToAsT picked No, let people ship whatever they want to ship. It's not about the yaoi.:
Man, anime fandoms are pretty scary... I hope it gets peaceful...
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
Yes. They have to be...
Edvygrl8 picked Yes. They have to be historically accurate of else I won't ship it. (Oh ._.):
Gits, insulting my own countries and everyone else. Bloody fnatards, who only cares about what Yaoi they can drool over. Headcanons, OCs, fanart, fanfics. Appeal that it. That all people like you care about. Not what you are actually saying you supprt, which I highly doubt you really do. Shallow gits, who are too lazy to care about your own history, let alone others. You don't deserve to be in the Hetalia fandom. Frankly, you stupid Americans are to lazy to even care about history. Doubt you even understand Hetalia at all. Reason I am never going back to America, all selfish shallow gits.
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
No, let people ship whatev- er...
FlyingTurtle picked No, let people ship whatever they want to ship. It's not about the yaoi.:
^ Again, judging a bunch of fans. I'm not even American, I'm Canadian. Plus every fandom has headcanons, ocs, fanart and fanfics, that's what makes a fandom.
Hey, I ship IceLiech, its my otp for hetalia. Its not yaoi. They dont have history together. Some people actually respect history, and they ship crack pairings in Hetalia. I dont think calling a bunch of fans shallow is nice.
I may have replied earlier with stupid comments, but dont judge a bunch of fans for their opinions.
Also not every Hetalia fan is American, you should of knew that, but nevermind.
It's okay to ship it for history. It's okay if the ship has no history. Just stop assuming the fans that ship crack pairings is an immature, crazy as hell 10 year old fan.
I don't like staying in the fandom because half of it judge and are rude to others for their own opinion, but I'm staying in it for my friends who I've become friends with from doing fandom things, like making headcanons, rping, fanfic writing, etc.
Hey, I bet you historical fans make headcanons as well. Like historical headcanons.
posted een jaar geleden.
last edited een jaar geleden
 
user photo
No, let people ship whatev- er...
muffins123 picked No, let people ship whatever they want to ship. It's not about the yaoi.:
FlyingTurtle : you are awesome. Like Prussia awesome. I like FrUk, but I also like AmeIta (it's my favorite crack pairing) I like crack pairings and actual pairings. Arguments like this make me want to just walk away from the Hetalia fandom. no wait, it makes me want to RUN from the Hetalia fandom. I'm really only staying because of my friends, who are in love with this show. ppl just need to realize that it's just Anime, and it's not the end of the world if some one likes a pairing that makes no sense. People are just too hot headed these days to sit back, and have fun with this show.
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
No, let people ship whatev- er...
black_amaranth picked No, let people ship whatever they want to ship. It's not about the yaoi.:
Ms. FlyingTurtle, you are one of the best people I've seen in this fandom. I honestly agree with all the things you say. I've seen a number of fans who give death threats to someone else, anouther actual being, because you they joked about a fictional character. Honestly, which one is more important? Being respectful to an actual person or an anime character? This people seriously need to grow up. I love Hetalia, and I respect it a lot, but to go as far as to insult anouther person, making insulting, offensive, Racist comments (you know who you are, miss), giving death threats and generally causing fights between someone I've never met in person? Over a fictional thing? Why can't people, who are always ranting about how immature some fangirls are, realise how childish THAT is?
posted een jaar geleden.
last edited een jaar geleden
 
user photo
No, let people ship whatev- er...
T045tToastToAsT picked No, let people ship whatever they want to ship. It's not about the yaoi.:
I agree with the last three people. All they want to do is pick fights, and that just proves they are immature. They make themselves look like spoiled, whiny babies. I mean honestly, why can't we all get along? It's ridiculous to fight over an anime. Totally ridiculous and immature.

@ FlyingTurtle: You are the besssst!!!! ^^
@ black_amaranth: You've said everything I wanted to say! :3 You are the best!
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
No, let people ship whatev- er...
amiZ picked No, let people ship whatever they want to ship. It's not about the yaoi.:
Wow, people need to seriously calm down... >.>

Shipping is purely for FUN. We don't need "reasons" or "rules" for shipping, wow. History or comic canon, country dynamics or character dynamics --- it doesn't really matter??? Ship whatever makes you happy. Geez, this entire debate is so silly.
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
No, let people ship whatev- er...
T045tToastToAsT picked No, let people ship whatever they want to ship. It's not about the yaoi.:
@ amiZ: IKR??? Shipping wars are so pointless! Seriously. All we're doing are arguing about fictional characters! That's it! We're making ourselves all look like idiots because we're arguing about something so pointless. I wouldn't argue over an ANIME. That's just a waste of time. You're basically arguing over a CARTOON. Do people really need to pick a fight? It's so immature. And it's so pointless. That's why I hate arguing in shipping wars. Because it gets you nowhere and you waste your time. Seriously. You don't gain anything from it. What's the point of it? Nothing. Seriously, bashing others just because of what they ship is really wrong. (And I'm not the only one that says that, I see a whole bunch of other people say that too. -_____-")
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
No, let people ship whatev- er...
Lesajevi picked No, let people ship whatever they want to ship. It's not about the yaoi.:
Well,personally I would prefer if the countries i'm shipping have some relation with each other in history instead of having absolutely nothing to do with the other but I have nothing against people who ship crack pairings or the crack pairings themselves. Pairings don't HAVE to be accurate for people to ship them.
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
No, let people ship whatev- er...
Greenwaves31 picked No, let people ship whatever they want to ship. It's not about the yaoi.:
I prefer them to have some historical or canonical backing, but I'll admit I do like some kind of cracky ships. And besides, everyone should be allowed to ship whatever they want. It's just for fun, right?

And oh my gosh, some of the comments on this. Seriously, some people are absolutely insane in this fandom.
posted een jaar geleden.
last edited een jaar geleden
 
user photo
Yes. They have to be...
pumpkinqueen picked Yes. They have to be historically accurate of else I won't ship it. (Oh ._.):
Toast: You still don't realize the characters are countries do you? With real life history, without Hetalia or the characters you are shipping wouldn't be there.

Green: If we're insane just because we don't want to shop for 'fun' which clearly means for eye candy and fanfictions, then I'll happily be insane if it means not insulting Himaruya or the actually countries by shipping them accurately and not just because they are 'cute/hot' or for the heck out it.
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
No, let people ship whatev- er...
Greenwaves31 picked No, let people ship whatever they want to ship. It's not about the yaoi.:
PQ: You're not insane for your opinion. What's insane is when people can't let OTHERS have an opinion. Also, I don't know how much good it will do since I've seen others point this out to you already, but Himaruya himself stated that he enjoys people having fun and pairing what they like in the fandom, so you're not insulting him by doing so. In fact, it's probably more insulting to him if you try to stop it. As for the coutnries, yeah, I can see your point, but you ship HongIce, so you can't tell anyone that they can't ship something for fun or because it's cute. There's plenty of historically accurate pairings for both of them. It's better to pair them with no history than bad history.
posted een jaar geleden.
last edited een jaar geleden
 
user photo
Yes. They have to be...
pumpkinqueen picked Yes. They have to be historically accurate of else I won't ship it. (Oh ._.):
Green: I don't ship HongIce actually, so that ends that statement. And frankly, I see no difference between no history and bad history, either way insulting.
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
No, let people ship whatev- er...
Greenwaves31 picked No, let people ship whatever they want to ship. It's not about the yaoi.:
PQ: Not what you said in your other comments~! Yay for getting insulted! That seems like a great way to spend my day. I think I'll try it more often. ^-^
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
No, let people ship whatev- er...
fandomfan picked No, let people ship whatever they want to ship. It's not about the yaoi.:
I think the point of Hetalia is to represent countries as people. Why shouldn't we ship people that don't know each other?
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
No, let people ship whatev- er...
GerItaGenius picked No, let people ship whatever they want to ship. It's not about the yaoi.:
You guys all need to chill. You people are the reason why the other fandoms hate us.
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
It depends.
CatLover9 picked It depends.:
i kinda want them to be historically accurate because ships like Prussia x Canada or Hong Kong x Iceland or Seychelles with every country on the globe with no connection at all... really bug me
posted een jaar geleden.