What do you think? Place your vote!
(Placed your vote already? Remember to login!)

Twilight Series when edward leaves Bella in New moon why dosent he tell her its for her saftey were he dosent hurt her as bad i mean he loves her right?

44 fans picked:
she wouldnt have been able 2 let go as easily (he...
she wouldnt have been able 2 let go as easily (he thought)
   75%
(added by stephmfan215)
Remember the scene in the hospital? that&# 39; s why.
Remember the scene in the hospital? that's why.
   16%
(added by Bookaholics)
I stell love him
   7%
Edward can be such a butt
   2%
 edward-lover456 posted een jaar geleden
Make your pick! | next poll >>
save

7 comments

user photo
she wouldnt have been able 2...
jasperloving picked she wouldnt have been able 2 let go as easily (he thought):
it was because she wouldnt have gotten over him
she would of said that she didnt care about her safety and that she just wantd to be with him
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
Remember the scene in the...
Bookaholics picked Remember the scene in the hospital? that's why.:
She freaks out whenever he mentions leaving "for her own good". if you'll remember, she nearly went mental when he said it to her in Twilight, when she was in the hospital in Phoenix. He knew she would go nuts if she thought that was the reason for his leaving, and thought for the sake of her sanity it was best for her to think he no longer loved her. Obviously he had no idea what the effect his leaving would have on her, because he didn't think she felt as strongly about him.
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
she wouldnt have been able 2...
babina picked she wouldnt have been able 2 let go as easily (he thought):
because he wanted her to think that he had moved on so that she can also move on! but if he had told her the truth she wldn't have let go! no that it worked but atleast he tried!

posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
Remember the scene in the...
AyaNox picked Remember the scene in the hospital? that's why.:
Bella doesn't bother about her safety. It doesn't matter to her, that it's dangerous or life-threatening. If he had told her, that he just leaves, 'cause he can't bear, that Bella isn't safe, she would've freaked out and there wouldn't have been the possibility, that she can forget him. When she knows, he loves her and leaves because of her, what do you think Bella would do? Let him go? Forget him? Or at least try to forget him?
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
Remember the scene in the...
jasmine052 picked Remember the scene in the hospital? that's why.:
He says he won't leave her but if he doesn't luv her anymore then he as no choice but 2 leave
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
she wouldnt have been able 2...
itailianjr120 picked she wouldnt have been able 2 let go as easily (he thought):
a clean brake
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
she wouldnt have been able 2...
Erilly picked she wouldnt have been able 2 let go as easily (he thought):
She would not understand the reason!
And not let him go!
And, yes, the scene in the hospital is perfect too show what i'm talking about!

<3
posted een jaar geleden.