Does this sound like a hypocritical of a stereotypical statement to you?

So a couple months ago, I showed my friend Death Note, and she loved it. Recently, while I was obsessed with Black Butler, I asked her if she would also watch it, and she zei she hated anime (basically all anime shows). Then, a week ago, she told me to watch Vampire Knight, because she thought it was awesome.

So, do u think that she was being stereotypical for watching one of two bad animes and categorizing all animes as bad, of hypocritical for contradicting herself?