What do you think? Place your vote!
(Placed your vote already? Remember to login!)

Critical Analysis of Twilight Do u guys think the only reason people hate twilight is because of the sparkly vampires?

78 fans picked:
No
   94%
Yes
   6%
 JennyRocker197 posted een jaar geleden
Make your pick! | next poll >>
save

23 comments

user photo
Renarimae picked No:
And plenty of their other reasons are very understandable.
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
Some people have only that reason. Others have many reasons.
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
zanhar1 picked No:
Thats just one reason. Edward is abusive. Bella only cares about Edwars looks. Bella seys a bad exsample for teens by getting pregnet. Bella always needs Jacob or Edward to come to her rescue. I could continue but Im sure its been herad before.
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
jamboni picked No:
I mean, the whole vampires sparkling thing is ridiculous, but I do give the author a little props because she atleast *tried* to give something different to the vampires we know.
But yeah, there a plenty of reasons I don't like Twilight..
posted een jaar geleden.
last edited een jaar geleden
 
user photo
Cinders picked No:
I've never met someone who dislikes and/or even goes as far as to express hatred towards Twilight who only had this for a reason. I also think that the people who don't like Twilight on this spot have been very vocal, clear, and generally respectful in voicing the myriad of reasons they have for not liking the books.
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
fanfly picked No:
The sparkly thing really doesn't bother me that much. Basically what jamboni said; she gets props for creativity even if I do think it's inexplicable and ridiculous.

But the way she romanticizes abusive relationships in a series about and targeted towards teens is inexcusable.
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
mari_giovani picked No:
I think real vampires fans dislike it, mainly, for that reason, but that's not the only bad thing about twilight
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
Mongoose09 picked No:
But I do NOT, I repeat, do NOT give the author props for creativity. It was like she asked the nearest 3 year old for ideas.

No way am I giving her props for ruining the concept of what a Vampire actually is.
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
Invader-Tak picked Yes:
Probably, but there are MANY other reasons as well.
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
death-eater picked No:
I hate every thing about Twilight ! sparkly vampires thing is only part of it
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
maryksand picked No:
Of course not. An author with a good sense of humor and good writing skills could make sparkly vampires hillarious and entertaining. But Meyer is not the one.

I dislike Twilight, because 1) it is very badly writen 2) it suffers from the lack of plot. I mean, a girl falls in love with a vampire who is 100 + years old virgin and during the whole series we read about how gorgeous, shiny, perfect, greek god like he is. The triangle thing (Edward/Bella/Jacob) was a total fail, because Meyer didn't even do a proper job in making Jacob more likable: he is just as abusive and stalking as Edward with one difference that at least Edward is not mentally ill and Jacob seems to have mental issues, which in the end lead him to imprinting on EB newborn child, which is totally sick and looks like pedophilia. 3) the characters are cliched. Just take Rosalie, she is blond and of course she has to be shown as a "bitch", same with Loren.


posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
bri-marie picked No:
Not at all. I've yet, like Cinders, to come across someone who only disliked Twilight because the vampires sparkled. I, personally, don't like the fact they sparkle, but I don't hate it. I think she could have been more "creative" or at least done it better.
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
Darkshine picked No:
It's sexist,poorly written,ridiculous,most characters are Mary-Sues/Gary-Stus,and the film/book gets too much insane fangirl attention.
More reasons needed?
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
MarlenaLovett picked No:
Of course not! But it didn't help.
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
EYBanuelos picked No:
There are many reasons why I hate Twilight.
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
bby11us picked No:
No; I really like it, but even as a fan, I can see the gaping holes of fail.
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
xDark_Angelx picked No:
People have many reasons to hate it, and most of it had nothing to do with sparkling.
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
HouseofNightRox picked No:
Its one of the many reasons though
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
TrueHufflepuff picked No:
No. No matter how everyone debates about vampires being ruined by the sparkling thing, I find it a silly reason to hate Twilight. There are much more, well-explained out and fully stated issues people have with this monsterpiece.
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
-Grace- picked No:
No. I give humanity the benefit of the doubt here and assume that no rational person would be that ridiculous. Although, I do think some of the reasons are quite petty, almost as though people are determined to dislike it :\
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
KissOfDoom picked No:
It's a ridiculus idea, sure, but I doubt that anyone uses it as a serious reason. It's really the least of the saga's problems.
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
hrrypttrfn328 picked No:
I hate it for many and varied other reasons.
posted een jaar geleden.
 
user photo
ixAthena picked No:
There are plenty of other reason for people hating Twilight. The failed plot, the Mary Sue/Marty Stu characters, fail vampires, etc.
posted een jaar geleden.