Cinderella was more of an improvement over the original, but I had more fun watching the new BatB.

They made Gaston less funny in the remake, and most of the sidekick characters had lost their charm. Also, the prologue had lost its gravitas.

So, I enjoyed Cinderella which managed to skip these pitfalls.

.

I watched Beauty and the Beast live action before Cinderella. I think I liked how beautiful Cinderella was, but I liked the additions of the original fairy tale versions (before Disney made it) with the mirror and being able to transport different places.

Some things I did not like was the autotune of Belle and I did not like the live action Fairy Godmother.

I love more Beauty and the Beast.

BATB is fine, but overally I prefer Cinderella.

This was far superior.

Beauty and the Beast lacks charisma, Cinderella wins.

Both are great!

Same with @SparkleFairy375's answer.

Emma Watson is ugly and can't act beyond the same "character" she plays in every movie.

Much more. It remained faithful to the original whilst adding new things without ruining it; I prefer the original but I like how Cinderella got to know the Prince more here. BatB has its moments but overall Cinderella felt more 'natural' to watch.

^ Mongoose09 I really liked how Cinderella got to know the prince, but the original was also pretty good, so I feel that the Beauty and the Beast remake was a little bit better since I liked it (mostly) more than the original. :)

The live action BATB is a disgrace.