No way, this cast is flawless.

If I could I would actually consider having Anne Hathaway play Belle, Joshua Rush play Henry, and have Hook and Neal switch actors. For some reason I feel like Neal's actor looks more like Captain Hook than Neal does, plus I would like to test my theory that Hook wouldn't be as popular if it wasn't for his looks, which we'll never know. Also I LOVE Anne and think she's an AMAZING actress, one of the best, but I love love Emilie and don't know if I could imagine anyone taking her place. I think Jared and Joshua are equally as good actors but I also am not sure if I can imagine anyone but Jared as Henry.

I might've considered changing Belle actually, Emilie is great, but I've not warmed to her as much as the rest of the cast (like even some minor characters), she always seems too hyper-active in interviews and she can come across as annoying sometimes. But her portrayal as Belle is good so I wouldn't replace her.

I probably have thought about this, but I can't remember anyone specifically...

I don't think I've disliked a single actor on this show. Even the characters I don't like I've never had anything against the actors.

The cast is perfect

No, I think it's perfect as it is!!! :D They're all great actors and very lovable, funny people.

But I'd find a way to squeeze Lara Pulver in.

If they had switched the roles of Neal and Hook, making Colin play Neal and MRJ play Hook, and if your theory were true, then everyone would like Neal because Colin is attractive. But you'd be okay with that?

The more you keep pushing that theory, the more I'm convinced that you care about looks more than you'd like to admit.

But as for the rest of the cast, I can't think of anyone else playing the roles. Some of the actors can get annoying, but at the same time, I can't imagine anyone else playing these characters.

Oh yes, I care about looks so much when one of the most attractive characters on the show, Hook, is one of my least favorite characters and Rumple and Neal are some of my favorite characters, who I don't find attractive. Your logic makes as much sense as saying the sky is blue because it's sad all the time. Get over yourself!

lol, nothing I said implied at all that I am full of myself in any way. I was merely making an observation and judging by your bristled response, I wouldn't be surprised if there was, in fact, some truth in my observation.

Just because a couple of your favorite characters "aren't as attractive" doesn't prove anything. In fact, your persistence in believing that we can't like Hook for his personality implies that maybe you can't see past his looks, so that must mean no one can.

Your theory is quite offensive to the actors of Rumple and Neal, though. Both of them are just as attractive as Hook. In my opinion, at least.

Your logic makes no sense! GET OVER IT! People like him because he's a good looking bad boy and for some reason girls like that and just ignore all the terrible things he's done. Unlike Rumple and Regina, who have also done horrible things, doesn't have as much development and isn't as sympathetic because we've seen plenty of their back stories for them to be well-rounded, while Hook is just half baked, just like the same arguments I hear when it comes to people defending him. This poll has nothing to do with Hook so why the heck are we even having this conversion? Get over it already!

Wow, temper. You get riled up easily.

I am a chemical imbalance! What's it to ya?

Absolutely nothing. My mother is, as am I. :)

If, by chemical imbalance, you're referring to the brain.

I have depression and it comes with being easily irritable

Ah, understandable. Bipolar, runs in the family apparently. Though my psychiatrist diagnosed me as "bipolar spectrum" or something when I was...17? I guess I'm not full bipolar, though it could develop into that as I get older.