Critical Analysis of Twilight

beantwoord deze vraag

Critical Analysis of Twilight Vraag

How come Edward could hear Renesmee's thoughts before she was born?

I mean, babies can't speak, right? Much less think for themselves. So how is it that Edward could hear what a FETUS was thinking?
Didn't think that one through very well, did you, Meyer?
*
That's pretty disturbing.
justliveitlive posted een jaar geleden
*
'Cause, like, y'know, like, Edward, like, is just, like, amazing, like that....
Mrs-Grint posted een jaar geleden
Hiding 2 comments... click to show.
*
maybe because the baby is half vampire and the fetus had really strong powers ? :P
bsfhn1 posted een jaar geleden
 tellymaster posted een jaar geleden
next question »

Critical Analysis of Twilight Antwoorden

AstridGoof8219 said:
Well, in my opinion, it's a pro-life thing. Since, Stephenie Meyer is a Mormon, and Mormons are usually pro-life, this could possibly be bringing a pro-life message as well as a message like, "The fetus loves you, so don't kill it, even if it's going to kill you."
 select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
*
Wrong. I am extremely pro-life, but this is just a lame excuse for Smeyer.
MusicMaker95 posted een jaar geleden
cassie-1-2-3 said:
A fetus does think, actually. They have brains.

Babies don't just suddenly start thinking as soon as they come out of their mother. Their brains develop in the womb. Some people even have actual memories of still being inside their mother.

Edward didn't start hearing her until her brain developed and she started thinking.
 select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
*
I know that they have memories and brains. My vraag is, how could Edward possibly know what she was thinking about?
tellymaster posted een jaar geleden
Hiding 11 comments... click to show.
*
^ It's a nice answer and a good subsequent debate. Do not condenscend.
Quaila posted een jaar geleden
*
@youknowit101: That was a little unnecessary. :/
-Alohomora- posted een jaar geleden
bri-marie said:
Actually, according to linkbabies can understand what's going on around them, even to the point where they can toon detestation to certain sounds.

Nessie wasn't a normal baby (hence why she sprouted four years in the space of a few months/weeks). Smeyer's logic was (probably) that Nessie's fast development started in the womb. It, in a way, makes sense that she would pick up words, understand their meaning, and be able to form coherent sentences. It was supposed to toon how different she was, how fast she grew and understood things.
 select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
*
I guess that makes sense. Thank you. I just find it a little scary that Nessie could think a language door the time she was three weeks in.
tellymaster posted een jaar geleden
*
I would not could on Smeyers logic- the lights on but no one is home...if u know what Im saying.
Persephone713 posted een jaar geleden
*
*count on not could on.
Persephone713 posted een jaar geleden
*
I find it scary that Nessie existed at all ;/
bri-marie posted een jaar geleden
Persephone713 said:
I dont know...But if my father told me he could hear my thoughts...I would tell him to get help.
 select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
*
I agree.
MusicMaker95 posted een jaar geleden
*
Same here.
tellymaster posted een jaar geleden
*
lol
kittyluvaxoxo posted een jaar geleden
*
Haha
g4eva posted een jaar geleden
rachaelwsz said:
Welcome to the World of Twilight.
 select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
swaggerberry said:
It's half human, half vampire. It grows at a rapid speed. door the time Edward heard the baby, it must have had thoughts already. It's strong also because it's half vampire.
select as best answer
posted een jaar geleden 
next question »
Cookies help us bring you Fanpop. By using Fanpop, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More Got It!