I voted for YES. I love Helena as Bellatrix, but I think she looks too good for somebody who's been in a horrible place like Azkaban for such a long time. I feel the same way about Emma's Hermione. Both women look too good in comparison to how they're portrayed in the books. I expacted a more unhealthy Bellatrix, a woman who looks tired and worn out, perhaps even some grey hair. Gary Oldman's Sirius looked more like somebody who just got out of Azkaban IMO.

Not really. I mean, Sirius and Barty Crouch Jr. didn't look like they'd been in Azkaban for years either.

In fact many movie characters look different from the book's ones!!!First of all Harry Potter himself has green eyes in the book but blue in the movie!!!Then movie hermione is very pretty,when the book says she is not!!!Same for Bellatrix too,she is freaking beautiful in the movies like she was never been in prison!!!And then there are the ones that the book says are very beautiful but we don't really see it in the movies,like Ginny and Narcissa!!!But well that doesn't really matter to me,i love the movies and i prefer them than the books!!!

Wow the littlest things really do annoy people don't they?

It doesn't really annoy and I absolutely love Helena as Bellatrix, me but I do agree that she looks too good for someone who has been in Azkaban for years.

Obviously, but magic could improve it, plus they won't portray ugly people on the screen cause nobody'll go to the movies.

Hey,did you not see her when they got her out of Azkaban? She looked mad ugly! And there's nothing a little magic couldn't do, and maybe she wasn't as stressed as the other prisoners cause remember how she was sitting in the chair in the ministry like a throne and that she was proud to take Azkaban for Voldemort ,so she probably enjoyed it more than others, plus she's not completely healthy, she's a little loony if u haven't noticed

I think that love for Voldemort allowed her to survive! :D

she looks far too normal to have been in azkaban. i mean sirius looked like a vampire when he got out. weird...

As much as I lover her and Helena yes, she should be much thinner dirtier and such. But it's not to big of a deal I mean I really dont expect Helena or any other actress to lose dangrous ammounts of weight just to play a certian role or anything like that.

I don't really mind so much, but yeah, she does look a bit too healthy for being stuck in Azkaban for years.

i'm tired of writing the same reasons when picking such picks
so i'll just say YES

^ Pretty much, I just summed it up.